Jump to content

Yvainnie

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    287

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Yvainnie

  1. Yvainnie
    Actually very good idea but I am still not sure that would surprise Syl so much if it would be just ordinary Adhesion stuff. But could be even though that would meant that on the ship he draw for completly different reason than in village.
  2. Yvainnie
    I think that if anything then this makes much more sense but still why built whole "I protect" thing just to have him abandon it for uniting which is clearly meant for Dalinar and Dalinar has some amazing development which would all be pointless. Also I think that for Kaladin to be responsible for Syl death it could only be reversible death like when he did not protect Elhokar.
  3. Yvainnie
    Agree on that. Why would they search for new Oathpact and torture and martyr. That is what got them in this mess in first place. They will look for something better, for solution and not just delaying tactic. It is all about people being unique and special so they can make it much more different this time around and may be end this for good with Odium gone forever, one way or the other.
  4. Yvainnie
    Well I dont think that in order to unite people you have to be Bondsmith. SA series seems to be about people who are not like old KR but something new and possibly better. Some of them are starting to grow beyond KR. Also I wonder if gloryspren are actually attracted to glory, I think they have wrong name and there is more to them than just glory.
  5. Yvainnie
    Romantic: Vin and Elend and also Vin and Kelsier
  6. Yvainnie

    [OB] Unmade

    Yvainnie posted a question in Cosmere Q&A

    What do you need to capture Unmade in perfect gem? Do you need Bonsmith or just any KR who understands it? Coppermind confused me with this, from Unmade page: But from Re-Shepir page:
  7. Yvainnie
    It was the very first thing that I thought when I read Kaladin chapters. It is pretty obvious that for this conflict to finally get solved, I mean really solved not just postponed, there have to be some special people and Kaladin wanted to protect all those people on both sides is first step but I am very curious about how will Sanderson tell sotry like this. Will Odium be ultimate evil or even his approach about passions and people needing them will start to make sense? In therms of leading I dont think Kaladin has to be leader to be protector and peacemaker he could be outside it all.
  8. Yvainnie
    Syl and other honorspren acted surprised when they saw what kaladin did and he did it first in the village. I think they would not be surprised if it would be just about 4th Ideal. I think that windspren can make Plate but Kaladin did something special, in the village he created "Plate" for all that people to get to safety before storm so I dont think it will be that easy. It is probably somehow connected to Plate but I think Kaladin will have some special abilites or may it is foreshadowing about what will happen after 5th Ideal.
  9. Yvainnie
    I think it is very unlikely. He thinks humself to be supreme justice and ultimate law and Odium thinks himself to be god of passions, that would not mix together well.
  10. Yvainnie
    Book is genius and perfect. I had a few problems with some characters but it has nothing to do with writing. It was just about me not liking people who were described so realistic. So Shallan part was interesting. Firstly I am amazed at how much accuretly Sanderson can desribe insane mind and development. It was very interestin to see how she was progressing deeper to spliting her mind but I kind of did not like her and Adolin but I like how she decided for herself even if it does not have to make sense to anyone else. Adolin was good and I hope he will bring Maya somehow back to be living spren. Kaladin was so much depressed but that was just his way. I do hope he will be better in next book and I was a little disappointed about him not saying 4th Ideal. And I so hope that he will end up having serious relationship with Syl! That would be awesome. And I was also diaspointed a little not to see any KR wearing true Plate. Humankind not being from Roshar was very good plot but I expected it but still awesome. And I also want to see what happens when someone will say 5th Ideal if 4th means that you get Plate. Dalinar and Odium were awesome. And: "I am unity." was my favorite part. Just perfect. I hope there will be more of that. I missed more Jasnah. I cried when Dalinar took that book and went to stand up to Odium.
  11. Yvainnie
    IIRC there is WoB that Roshar was created by Adolnasium so storing in a gem can be from him and not related to Roshar.
  12. Yvainnie
    Good theory but I dont know how it would fit with what I think I read somewhere that 16 people decided to kill Andolsium because they think it was their only option. But storms! I forget where I have seen it.
  13. Yvainnie
    Interesting idea, Shadowthrone. I wonder if there is WoB somewhere about Yolen being visited or talked about.
  14. Yvainnie
    Yup, he said it much better, besides where else would be God of hatred than in Hell? But coppermind Wiki sais that Voidbringers were cast down to heaven and Heralds followed to fotce them out of heaven, so that goes for theory that Braize is Tranquiline Halls but what about damnation? Does it means that they are the same place.
  15. Yvainnie
    From coppermind wiki but I thought I read something like that in WoK (I think one of Shallan chapters) but you have take my word with pinch of salt, or copper http://coppermind.net/wiki/Damnation
  16. Yvainnie
    Interesting thought but then Roshar could not be between them but Halls could also meant to be spiritual realm. And couldn't Khriss by Cognitive Shadows mean just Heralds alone?
  17. Yvainnie
    Agreement? This could be Oathpact? Why did Heralds go to Braize and fought?
  18. Yvainnie
    Braise?
  19. Yvainnie
    Is there any way how connected red eyes to red stars, if it is not Odoum influence then it could be related to those stars? Shattering is good idea but how and where?
  20. Yvainnie
    Which ones? And do you please have a link on specific thread about this?
  21. Yvainnie
    I don't know about red stars but in BoM they mention Red Haze? And according to what Wax see when he is talking to Harmony I think that it is visible sign of Shard attack.
  22. Yvainnie
    Braize is the third planet from the system's sun know as Damnation. Roshar, which exists in between the Halls and Damnation is second planet. Is Ashyn Tranquiline Halls? the first planet?
  23. Yvainnie
    And if it is the case? I mean he knows about making shades but not Odium influenced shades. I think they made congnitive shadows of purpose because of what he said in M:SH but that doesn't mean they have to be twisted yet. Nice. Thanks for clearing that up. I wonder what does mean that it is significant. Does it mean that causes for red eyes are somehow connected but not by one Shard?
  24. Yvainnie
    Crazy theory but... So according to Arcanum Unbounded there was some fight on Threnody between Odium and Autonomy and we know that shades are cognitive shadows. And in Mistborn: Secret History Nazh mentioned that to became a shadow there are some requirements and traditions and what if Nazh is from pre-Evil Threnody and they are creating shades on purpose, to become sort of ascended or immortal but fight between Shards twisted them into shades. On Roshar influence of Odium is connected to red eyes and on Thenody if shades are enraged their eyes turn red so what if it means they are influenced by Odium in that moment and they attack. And in Bands of mourning Epilogue there is Faceless Immortal with red eyes that could also mean it is not kandra but cognitive shadow from Threnody under influence of Odium that Ire in Mistborn: Secret History were afraid of?
  25. Yvainnie
    Then why it is not black when it later appeared to Vin? Vin did not see any difference between Ruin and Preservation as mist spirits, surely she would notice if one of them was black, no?
×
×
  • Create New...