Jump to content

Stick.

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    3863

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Stick.

  1. Stick.
    Oh yea true, can’t deny that edit: he’s since then clarified he wasn’t in contact with tj so the point is moot fmpov but I understand this interpretation coming from you edit1: I’ll vote between Aman TKN and Drake today
  2. Stick.
    yeah they havent responded to it yet and instead provided a gut read last eod and i assumed it was because they were short on time i still wanna hear it shading wonko? :p. i think ive been quite vocal in village reading him since last cycle
  3. Stick.
    im not sure i understand this :p.
  4. Stick.
    ok maybe i am wrong but idk why jabberwock!tkn would kill someone cursed by time when he'd know, being cursed by time himself, that it is a thing that exists in this minigame too. like i said, i assumed it ended with the last one edit: currently being persuaded by wonko in PMs, it's entirely possible tkn didnt anticipate it and think it through hard enough
  5. Stick.
    hey, no, come back and explain that :p. tkn could be elim yea but prob not the jabberwock
  6. Stick.
    also the sword TJ held has been passed on to another villager most likely
  7. Stick.
    the jabberwock wouldnt wanna kill TJ because they need all the kills they can get, no? they probably had no clue what TJ's role was. edit: honestly im midly confused as to why people dont think im the jabberwock off that kill jabberwock likely thought TJ was elim im sorry if my TJ read contributed to that LMAO i have forgotten how to village
  8. Stick.
    PMs from last minigame carry over to this one, so if there was knowledge of TJ having made PMs with people there it should be shared Edit: like I can prove I didn’t have any PMs with TJ because I used my c1 action to create one with TKN, used my c2 action to kick wonko out of the tea party (lol) and used by c3 action to create a PM with dead!mat. During c4 I used the special c4 ability and I would have mentioned PMs with TJ when explaining why I was voting for him edit2: experience would have made a PM with TJ I don’t think TJ would have role claimed to anybody except for maaaybe wonko, because I know that wonko had been offering people role swaps and even just TJ refusing the role swap would’ve maybe pointed towards him having a stronger role that he felt the need to hide Edit3: BTW I can confirm that redirection to self mechanics exist in that game and it’s possible TJ had that and it resulted in two instead of one kill on him edit4: @Experience please explain what info you gleaned off exaggerating Mat's defense of ash
  9. Stick.
    Who did TJ have PMs with other than wonko
  10. Stick.
    I was never cursed by time - TKN was though. Wonko PM’d me last cycle too. I don’t think he’s restricted to a single action like most of us - or at least he wasn’t last cycle. I think the simplest explanation is just that we got an outdated flip because wonko was cursed by time and that the jabberwock didn’t anticipate this. Shouldn’t that clear TKN as not-Jabberwock? TKN would know that being cursed by time carries over from the last minigame. I’d assumed everybody started with a clean slate but apparently not. If the jabberwock themself was cursed by time, I think both of those flips should have been outdated - not just wonkos? Amanuensis
  11. Stick.
    Experience probably slight slight villagery for that vote, I was being wolfy in PMs with them Edit: though @Experience you might wanna self pres onto Alpha because there might be vote manip (I suspect the jabberwock at least has some idk about the elims)
  12. Stick.
    labyrinth gn
  13. Stick.
    LOL it's my 'would kill today' pile but i mean when you say it like that, i guess it kind of is that too? but no, tj/sart have posted more than wonko
  14. Stick.
    <TKN, Scars, Wit, xino, Aman, Sart, TJ, Labyrinth> big list, hopefully there's plenty of flips to look forward to tomorrow ;eyes; ive taken mat out for today for being solvey in PMs but it's not a village read yet because sometimes he be saying things that dont villager villagery enough. i dont love the line about the jabberwock yeah @Labyrinth hope your family member gets well!!
  15. Stick.
    i think the first sentence is villagery and the second is somehow equally elimmy lmao experience, what's your own read on mat? edit: because earlier you seemed to be sussing mat: but are now implying elims jumped on the train, so im curious if you think the elim here was being opportunistic or just distancing edit: aaaaand i definitely led too much into the answer there T-T
  16. Stick.
    wonko straight up REJECTING my village read is VILLAGERY u_u i dont think ash should die today. he's implied something in his posts but i could be reading into it too much so lolme I think TJ is a fine vote - i think he had 'distracted' vibes in his posts at SoD, particularly in his convo with mat. Then i got slight pings from his post indirectly sussing wonko in response to my elaborated gut read, and now i have a feeling this recent readslist looks wolf shaped. i couldnt explain what that means to myself so dont ask xD. The bottom tier is very consensus-y. that said, im leaning town on quin so i agree there. i dont understand my placement though :p. edit: i dunno how to read sart ._.
  17. Stick.
    TJ
  18. Stick.
    You think Mat tried to pocket ash by defending him in private comms with experience? :p. This implies you think both ash and experience must be village. Is this accurate?
  19. Stick.
    I too have asked exp in PMs why Mat defended ash LMAO
  20. Stick.
    My wonko read is basically that he’s still hung up on the last game and hasn’t made any (visible) efforts to solve the current one. I would expect elim!wonko to try to appear “villagery” by tying to solve here (maybe throwing out some distro speculation or a read or two) given how driven he was to achieve his wincon last game. I will say this read is exclusive to wonko only for obvious reasons and I’m not applying to, say, Xino or TKN, who have also only spoken about the previous game.
  21. Stick.
    do you agree with mat's self-assessment that he's been unfairly quick to wagon you lately? as ive typed that im realising you said this was your first game in a year, no? o.O curious.
  22. Stick.
    Ok you have sold me on three bandersnatches and now I’m formally accusing exp of having displayed elimmy TMI edit: ive now talked myself out of that read and think exp is village i think wonko is village Mat and TJ are not teamed - not a difference check so can be v/v but if i had to sus one it would be TJ first Ash is outed as not-villager
  23. Stick.
    Scars of Hathsin
  24. Stick.
    I think three elims here is prob unreasonable given we only get three exes and there’s a SK to deal with, because it means that if we correctly exe 2 bandersnatches and the jabberwock in these three cycles consecutively, we still don’t win but neither does the jabberwock nor the bandersnatches, I think? So it’ll come down to a stalemate? I agree with exp that there’s probably extra kill power with a villager. Either that or there’s a role more informed than regular villagers somewhere. Without extra KP, if you take into account the exe, the NK and the SK kill - we’d be down to 14 —> 11 —> 8 —> 5 players by the end of the third cycle. Im guessing two bandersnatches. A town coinshot to help them dwindle numbers down. The jabberwock might be the informed role here. Kinda like Devo’s role in MR56. Anyway, talk more about those PM vibes @Matrim's Dice?
  25. Stick.
    absolutely
×
×
  • Create New...