Hi folks. I used to hang around TWG and I've been reading AoL, which means it's time to get back into Sandersonian forums. So thanks for having these wonderful forums!
Reading the Ars Arcanum on this topic made me think about something I considered long ago: Hemalurgy and Breath.
If I spike someone and myself, can I steal their breath?
I have a better one. Let's make a few baseless assumptions:
a: an Allomancer can obtain and use breath
b: Gunther, over there, is a Pewterarm.
The following then occurs:
1)Gunther collects breaths and awakens a scarecrow.
-does this awakened scarecrow possess the ability to burn pewter? He lacks the physical requirements, certainly, but that's the same scenario as Gunther himself being out of Pewter. Just because he lacks the means to burn pewter doesn't mean he lacks the capacity.
2) Gunther, being a man learned in the Spiritweb of straw people, spikes the scarecrow.
Does he steal its investiture? Has Gunther created a Pewterarm spike, using Breath to pay the cost in life and blood? Would he need to use some blood as part of the awakening process, similar to Vasher's use of his own hair?
If this can be pulled off, you have something quite fascinating. using the warm and friendly Awakening, as well as the twisted and disturbing Hemalurgy, you come out with a way to freely hand out any magic to anyone. You just... have to survive the implant. How's that for "interest to the Cosmere"?
---
I don't really expect anyone to respond to this with a solid "yes, you are completely 100% correct." But feel free to point out where Brandon's said things that would patently foil this concept. More importantly: food for thought. Enjoy.