thejopen27 Posted March 27, 2014 Report Share Posted March 27, 2014 What other theories do you have Moogle? I bet we disagree on them. Do you think Taln is a fake? This is the second or third time I've disagreed with you on a topic, it makes it more fun. Syl disapproved of what Kaladin was doing the whole book but she didn't start to diminish until Kaladin got out of prison and he promised Moash he'd help kill Elhokar (which also went against the first ideal and assassination is inherently dishonorable as the target doesn't see it coming which is possibly in violation of protecting those who can't protect themselves). Syl is Honorspren, she is drawn to Honor. When Kaladin makes an oath to Moash to kill Elhokar he promised to do something directly in conflict with at least the first ideal, possible the second, and definitely the third ideal. To Syl oaths are sacred and making an oath is probably similar to the action itself. Therefor Kaladin wasn't in trouble thinking about whether or not to kill Elhokar or Amaram although Syl didn't like it and tried to convince him not to, he doesn't get in trouble until he makes a decision and commits to killing Elhokar. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts