Jedi vs Mistborn

[the Gleeman he/him]

Ok so, a big question debated between my friends is whether a jedi could fight a mistborn and win assuming a lightsaber is an investure-charged metallic object and the force can be sensed using brass. I for one go for the jedi but what are your opinions?

Edited November 7, 2014 by the Gleeman

[Jo and the Bush all/any]

Let's Rule out Atium at the very start shall we?

 

Well, a Misborn has increased Physical abilities due to Pewter, but that's negated by the Force. 

Mistborn can move Metallic Objects around in set ways, while Jedi can move anything around in any way.

Jedi don't wear any Invested clothing though, so Soothing and Rioting can affect them, so a Duralumin Burn could easily pacify them.

Copper could probably block out a Jedi's Life Force as well.

 

So in an honorable Duel, the Jedi would win. Ina street fight, the mistborn would win.

 

So I vote Mistborn, since they don't participate in Honorable Duels, but Jedi Participate in Street fights.

[Redbird he/him]

It seems you finally made this poll, also, some points to consider:

Rioting emotion would actually be very bad for most Jedi, the same thing for soothing a sith. Unless you are talking about Revan, then he would win either way. 

Also, isn't atium kind of like the glimpse of the future force sensitives see in a fight, except kind of more exact and reliable?

I just realized something, a fight between inquisitors would be interesting, steel inquisitor vs. sith inquisitor.

Edited November 7, 2014 by Redbird3000

[Voidus]

Mistborn shoots coin, Jedi blocks, coin turns into molten slag, mistborn keeps pushing on it, Jedi has molten metal on his face.

Mistborn wins.

[Briar King]

Given my love for SW I say Jedi hands down esp if you factor in what the EU Jedi brought to the table. Sad that's now gone but movie Jedi can't give you what Jedi can do.

[Crash & Charm he/him]

In a formal honorable duel the mistborn would still win. The jedi can't out maneuver a mistborn.

[Briar King]

The Force could stop a leaping Mistborn dead in their tracks.

[Jo and the Bush all/any]

Could the Force stop the Iron Ingot from hitting the Jedi in the Back?

[Redbird he/him]

The problem seems to be; which jedi, and which mistborn?

Edited November 14, 2014 by Redbird3000

[Briar King]

The problem seems to be; which jedi, and which mistborn?

Yeah, plus it goes back to what I was saying if it was EU or movie Jedi.

EU Jedi would certainly and very easily be able to stop a coin going toward their backs.

[Jo and the Bush all/any]

Well Then, Let's Pick Specifics. How about Kelsier vs. Luke? (Movie 6)

Edited November 15, 2014 by The Only Joe

[Briar King]

ROTJ Luke is a wuss lol

[Voidus]

Given my love for SW I say Jedi hands down esp if you factor in what the EU Jedi brought to the table. Sad that's now gone but movie Jedi can't give you what Jedi can do.

Hasn't like the whole EU been declared non-canon now?

[Briar King]

Indeed. That's why I said sad it's now gone. All EU has been flushed away. Sure most of the Arcs after NJO kinda sucked but I spent 1,000's of $ and 20 yrs of my life reading them all.

[Redbird he/him]

Which means we lose the Thrawn trilogy, which were actually quite good.

[Silus - Shard of Flame he/him]

Perhaps Kelsier vs Mace Windu would be a better match?  Or maybe Elend as a Lerasium Mistborn?