samsocial

5 minutes ago, Frustration said:

He still has to deal with Yesteel.

why seek him? why not stay in city , prepare and wait ?

4 minutes ago, Frustration said:

A pot will hold water, but if you break it into pieces it won't.

but water is still there, why it cannot be put in a new pot ?

4 hours ago, KaladinWorldsinger said:

Deadeyes are stuck in their shardblade form in the physical realm until they are bonded to people using an embedded gemstone. Then whenever these shardblade are dismissed they appear in shadesmar.

I am not sure about his. Someone correct if I am wrong

9 minutes ago, Quantus said:

as I understand it they both exist simultaneously for the most part.

When Maya travels to Lasting Integrity with Adolin, no one knows her. if when dismissed she appears in shadesmar someone should know her.

Also, where are dead-eys of other shardbaldes  owned by other high prices ? why we do not meet them in shadesmar?

How all deadeyes travelled to Shadesmar after they were dead ?

Who brought them back ? How?

Also are there 20 thousand blades somewhere in physical realm waiting to be discovered ?

18 hours ago, Frustration said:

The last time he gave people commands like that it causes the manywar.

Then isn't it more responsible to stay back and see what he has given to people is put to good use ?

13 hours ago, Boomerang Guy said:

Yes

?

On 11/8/2021 at 0:18 AM, Frustration said:

He was going mad because of Odium's attack.

why? why he did stop Odium ? 

On 11/8/2021 at 0:18 AM, Frustration said:

the power is still around but cannot take a new vessel

why ?

Why Vasher leaves in end? It is still unsure if stone soldiers would succeed the battle.

Plus he has so much knowledge about breath, He knows how to gives breaths without giving the life breath.

why not share that with other gods or god king staying in city?

Why not help with peace between 2 nations/states ?

What is more important than this ?

30 minutes ago, Frustration said:

And the Sibling was able to command the Oathgate at Theylanah, so even the ones away from Urithiru were subject to them.

Lol, what command did she execute? Even Fuzed passed through the gate and she did nothing.

We know that Honor is dead from stormfather. We also know that his vessel was Tanavest, who was killed by Odium.

It might be stupid question but, I do not understand what exactly died.

Is it the vessel that was carrying Honor died? If yes, why can't it be replaced by a new one?

Or is it Honor itself that died? If yes, what happened to his investiture? Is it still there somewhere? Or it is now shared with Odium and Cultivation?

When Honor got mad, is it Tanavast who got mad or it was Honor itself? How can a god get mad ? I understand that it was because of thousands of years of battle, torture, etc. By definition he is supposed to live thousands of years. If he is unable to cope the time what's the point in having him as a god?

On 5/11/2021 at 6:26 PM, Frustration said:

The Sibling forbade CR travel using Oathgates.

There are many oathgates. Sibling had control on only one at Uritheru. Why can't they be used? Also, how come Shalan was able to open one at the battle of Narak?

On 5/11/2021 at 0:22 PM, Alcatur said:

There certainly were many Radiants who broke their oaths in the past,

Where are sprens of these "oath-breaker-but-spren-saver" radiants?

On 5/11/2021 at 0:22 PM, Alcatur said:

Nearly the entire membership of Windrunners and Stonewards was killed shortly after Feverstone Keep incident. 

Nearly ? You yourself doesn't seem sure how many died. Nearly implies that someone survived. What did they do? Nothing? Was that honorable for a (former) radiant?

7 hours ago, Valigus said:

Because they are physically entering through a perpendicularity

By that logic, sprens too should not change their appearance when they enter to physical realm via perpendicularly

On 7/10/2021 at 8:53 PM, AquaRegia said:

It's hard to understand for people who DON'T have "shameful" pasts or serious mental health challenges... but it's quite normal to keep secrets from the ones you love most.  The fear of losing their love once the truth is out is an incredibly powerful motivation, even in cases where it's unfounded. 

There's nothing wrong in Shalan not telling Adolin about her murdering her parents. But if Kaliden knows this there is always a possibility of Adolin getting that information from Kaliden. This would be more terrible for their relationship. There's more fear of losing love by not being honest. Logically it doesn't make sense to hide this from Adolin when someone close to him already knows the secret.

In chapter 13 of steel heart, reinforcement starts. David tells us that it is prerecorded and we don't know when it was recorded.

In same recording steel heart destroys multiple buildings. Why then it is not possible for anyone to know the time of recording. It was definitely done when those buildings were destroyed, right? Why rekners could not backtrack and find the exact date and time? Why in the first place they did not know anything about destruction of these buildings?

3 hours ago, Frustration said:

It wasn't at the same time. Feverstone keep was just Windrunners and Stonewards, the other orders did so at different times. However

1. Once oaths were broken none of them had a way to check on their spren to see the effects
2. Even if they did find out Windrunners broke oaths first, there would have been no way to communicate it to the others.

Why there was no way to check sprens? They could have travelled to shademar using oath gates, perpendicularity, etc, if they did not break oaths same time that means there were still people travelling to shadsmar using oath gates operated by Radiant blades 

Why Windrunners cannot communicate with others? They can speak, right? 

Is Let's go Brandon used for Sanderson?

Jasna is OK to kill the Harards and nothing happens to her Spren 
Whereas Kalidan helped to kill Elohkar and He almost killed Syl 

What was Jasna's oath?

4 hours ago, Frustration said:

He only had one at that time. 

15 hours ago, Bearer of Agonies said:

he had a bunch of Breaths saved up.

aren't these 2 statements contradictory ?

How come Taravangien did not die using it against Odium ? He doesn't have stormlight. What investiture did he use?

Getting a new breath every week for 350 years, it should not be that much sensory overload for a person like Denth

I don't get, if he is used to getting new breaths, why he is surprised like a newbie when Vashar gives him his breaths?

If Denth is one of the 5 scholars, how did he survive without 1 breath/week?

If yes, how it goes from one person to another ?

Why Zeth did not die when he drew  it? Does he have more then one breath ?

We know that Radiants broke oath and killed sprens.

How come all of them did it at once? 
Wasn't there trial and error to check the consequences ?
 
Radiant are all over Roshar, how did they manage to inform this to each and every Radiant 
Was there an annual gathering of Radiants where they did this ritual? 

How come none of them denied/accidently survived by lack of communication?

Also, the way different Radiants break oath seems different for each Radiant
Jasna is OK to kill the Harards and nothing happens to her Spren 
Whereas Kalidan helped to kill Elohkar and He almost killed Syl 

Then how all the ancient Radiants managed to break oaths at the same time ?

13 hours ago, earthexile said:

Shardblades and Shardplate are very much not the same material, and don't work the same way at all. Blades are lighter than normal metal, completely impossible to harm, and can be summoned by the person bound to them, whereas Plate is heavier than the same amount of normal metal, can be shattered even by ordinary weapons and big falls, and you have to spend an hour getting bolted into it.

I see, but why then it is named similarly ? is there any similarity ?