Jump to content

Creccio

Members
  • Posts

    263
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Creccio

  1. Ripple, Is there any other reason than it being a subconscious reaction? Referring to the lynching as most likely a Skaa and claiming it on a confusion just does not roll for me. We have been talking about a plan to get the Skaa since page one, not only that, but on the rules it is clearly stated the the Skaa are the bad guys in the game, on top of that, there were a good 2-3 posts on math behind our chances of hitting a Skaa/Villager. You have been active in the thread (Since page 2, afaik) and I do not believe you just "forgot, it can't be a coincidence. Give me some good reasoning --other than "other games skaa=good"--, or else my vote is on you. Ripple
  2. There is no alignment detecting role, uh...? (Misread on my part, kek) That complicates things... now, if there was a role like that i would wait, but having nothing like that makes things harder. We should then discuss, who to lynch --if lynching is the best option in your eyes-- and let that person defend themselves. Let the "Contribution Crusade" do their work, but mind you, Eliminators are aware and should be active, so i see little benefit in only going after inactive persons they might just not understand a thing and stay on low profile.
  3. I am not a fan of day 1 lynches. We have no information to base our decisions on and no one has had a chance to actually gain information. We might just kill a Skaa, yes, but we might also kill the one player with the Atium powers. Day 1 is a coin toss and I'm firmly against lynching anyone today. It makes no sense from a information point of view and from a math point of view, lets put it like this, we have 5 boxes, one of them is a Skaa, do you trust yourself enough to pick the right one? Mind you i believe there is 5, not 6 as Adavantos has pointed out, and, 5/26 = 0.19 or 19%, so even my box example is giving us a 1% advantage. I think we should not kill anyone today, that's just depriving any information they might have for tomorrow.
×
×
  • Create New...