David is exceptionally good at copying what Prof does. I think that he just never thought that was a possibility, since he hadn't seen Prof do it.
Regarding Nightwielder's spears, if the force fields can block those, then I'd say that Prof wouldn't have any problems dealing with Nightwielder.
And why do you say the offensive crushers act differently? We do know that Prof can set the fields to block different things, such as just heat. So while he could be setting different fields to do different things, I certainly didn't get the impression that they are very different.