Disclaimer: I have not yet read Eleventh Metal or Secret History, I will be reading them tomorrow.
I am feeling disappointed in the way Era 2 has gone so far. I was so optimistic after the Alloy of Law. It was a nice, fast-paced intro to the new generation, and while it didn't have the most grand or epic plot, it was okay, it was the first novel in the series, no biggie.
Then Shadows of Self was a little bit of a mess in my opinion, and while it had its moments of course, I thought it was way too busy and convoluted. Despite a good ending, with really nice emotional consequences it seemed for Wax, I didn't like that book very much. But, hey it was Book 2, that just happens sometimes.
On to the Bands of Mourning. Started out nice, although Wax' trama wasn't as pronounced as I would have thought. Steris became one of my favorite characters in the series all the way through the party scene and then promptly did... pretty much nothing the rest of the book. Wayne became a caricature of himself this whole book and I really didn't like him this time. To me he is a very sincere character who puts on an act to cover up his pain and pureness of heart, like 70% sincere and 30% goofy. In this book he was maybe 30% sincere and 70% buffoon. Ugh.
Then the stakes just felt really shallow. This person's dead! Nope just kidding, now this person's dead, gotcha! They're fine. *insert Oprah* You can heal, you can heal, everybody can heal!!!
Sigh.
Maybe my expectations were just too high. After the first and even the end of the second book I thought we were really going to explore some darker themes and have some real stakes. I feel like I just watched Avenger's Endgame or Rise of Skywalker. Let's go chase a macguffin and dont worry no one you like is gonna be in any real danger.
I'm ranting, I just want y'all to know I have a lot of positive things I like about Era 2 as well, but the second half of BoM left a sour taste in my mouth. Here's hoping Secret History helps.
Any discussion is welcome, I would love to work through these feelings with y'all!