-
Posts
29 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Posts posted by EnaMai
-
-
Awesome thanks Serial! I knew someone must have the second half. Feel free to use that google doc to transcribe if you want to. Regardless, I'm excited to hear all those questions!
0 -
Sure! Here's the full transcript. I did paraphrase questions about writing, other authors' books, WoT, etc (or when the question audio is indecipherable but I remember the gist of it from the event).
plain = verbatim
italicized = paraphrased
[00:26]
Q: In Words of Radiance you have a great line which said “careful planning is the water which nourishes creativity”. I was wondering if, when you wrote that line, were you specifically thinking about novel outlines?
A: So there’s a line in Words of Radiance that’s says “careful planning is the water which nourishes creativity”. Was I specifically thinking of outlines? So when I speak most lines like this, I’m trying to speak through someone’s eyes. That’s Navani I believe who says that am I right? The idea being that that’s the way they’d perceive it. There are other people who would disagree. Now I am a planner, so I understand that mindset a lot. I use a lot of outlines. There are other people who don’t plan at all and their books still turn out awesome. So I think there are a lot of different ways to be creative. But I don’t think that Navani thinks that there are a lot of different ways. If that makes any sense. She has a different perspective on it perhaps.
[01:36]
Q: Revisiting the Wheel of Time?
A: Robert uncomfortable with people writing in his universe. Changed his mind in the end. Harriet and Brandon presented a united front to publisher. It shouldn’t happen b/c of Robert’s wishes. Harriet and the estate may change their mind but he probably wouldn’t write them himself.
[4:00]
Q: What about a WoT movie?
A: Could happen but TV show more likely.
[4:44]
Q: So this may be RAFO bait, but in Dalinar’s Feverstone Keep vision, when the Radiant’s discard their Shards are they doing that to any entity in particular in specific?
A: Definitely a RAFO.
[5:04]
Q: Last month you posted a picture of your Dropbox right and there is that one folder that we read about. Is there anything you can tell us about that yet?
A: So I posted a picture of my Dropbox and I just happened to have crossed out one of the folders. Ahm, what can I say about that...you’ll know eventually. There’s not a whole lot i can say about it because it’s mere existence is a spoiler to people who haven’t read certain other books. And so that’s the reason why I crossed it out.
Q: We can assume it’s Cosmere?
A: I can’t say either way. It’s mere existence is a spoiler. You will find out eventually, but it is definitely a little side project that I may or may not actually ever finish.
[6:07]
Q: What are you reading right now?
A: The Martian by Andy Weir (fantastic), Naomi Novik’s new book, The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks, Raising Steam, Peter Orullian’s second book
[7:45]
Q: If your character Hoid were a Planeswalker what color would he be?
A: You know I might do him like the Reaper King. Like two slash on all five. That’s what I would do him as.
[8:24]
Q: Inspiration for Cody?
A: At a convention in the South a guy used y’all for “me”; for one person. Built a character around this person. A Kentucky dialect is y’all for one person and all y’all for many. Gets many emails from Southerners letting him know that’s not right.
[9:52]
Q: Who would I cast to play Wayne in Alloy of Law?
A: He doesn’t cast characters; pays attention to directors. Impressed by Matthew McConaughey these last few years. Best actors are versatile. He cast the Legion hallucinations as famous actors except for Kalyani.
[10:52]
Q: Plans to make tabletop RPGs for other books?
A: Eventually we will do them, but not anytime soon.
[11:15]
Q: How do you pitch a book?
A: Practice...
[13:01]
Q: Inspiration for Szeth?
A: Discovery writes his characters. Writes characters into a plot like casting them into roles. For Szeth it came from the idea of a religion worshipping stone.
[14:32]
Q: Most unforgettable frustrations of becoming a writer?
A: Meeting deadlines; trained himself to be creative and excited about necessary book. Touring also exhausting.
[15:38]
Q: Which power would you have in the real world?
A: Allomancer. Steel/Iron. Others would keep you alive or give immortality but he wants to fly.
[16:14]
Q: So I’m asking a question for my little sister. So since Disneyland is taking over the world, Disneyland is obviously Librarians. So is Alcatraz ever going to visit Disneyland?
A: Oh that’s a good question. He should because Disneyland is totally Librarians. They totally run that. I will consider that. I will consider that. Good question. Alcatraz 5 is written. We’re re-releasing the Alcatraz books with new covers and new artwork and all sorts of cool things like that starting January next year and they’ll run straight through to the fifth book which will come out in the summer sometime.
[17:05]
Q: How do you keep everything straight?
A: He has an internal wiki with [WikiDPad?]. He’s scatterbrained; forgets wallets, keys, but never forgets stories. They stick in his head.
[17:47]
Q: Will you tell us the Intent of Bavadin’s Shard?
A: The Intent of Bavadin’s Shard? No. But good question. Have a RAFO card.
[18:14]
Q: If you could talk [?] optioning Stormlight Archive.
A: Have I thought of optioning Stormlight as a miniseries? Yes I have, but I think it’s premature if you do anything until a few more books come out.
[18:29]
Q: Should the things you thought of in Firefight apply in Steelheart?
A: Yes, the things I thought of in Firefight should apply in Steelheart. Uh, about weaknesses.
[18:53]
Q: Who’s your favorite Epic?
A: Ask in line, since it’s a spoiler for the books. It’s someone that you don’t know is an Epic.
[19:07]
Q: Syl changes forms a lot more than the other bonded spren. Is human her default?
A: Is Syl’s default form the little human woman or does she not really have one? You will find out more about that eventually.
[19:31]
Q: How do they work with spheres being the money, magic system, and lighting on Roshar?
A: They would say, “How could you have three different things to fulfill those functions?” Mostly rich people use spheres for lighting. Poor people use candles and such since you don’t want to leave your spheres out in the open. There are low-light spheres worth the same amount as a candle, so someone could swipe that and there wouldn’t be a difference.
[20:40]
Q: What does the Upside Down [??? sorting system] exactly mean?
A: [laughing] I don’t know, it’s something I made up for the Librarians in Alcatraz.
[21:21]
Q: What advice would you give to someone who wants to be a writer?
A: Your duty is to practice writing in such a way so you can write great books. Your job is not to write a great book. It takes practice, like being a doctor or pianist. Resolve to practice. Don’t worry if you’re not playing Rachmaninoff immediately. Practice trumps perfectionism on a small level.
[32:14]
Q: The Shardblade that Dalinar had at the end of Words of Radiance, was that the Honorblade?
A: The Shardblade that Dalinar had at the end of Words of Radiance that he gave up?
Q: Yeah, that he gave up.
A: No it was not.Q: It was not? So what happened to the Honorblade that the Herald had?
A: Nobody kno- Well, somebody knows, but it is not known to the main characters.
Q: Can I ask if uh, Hoid-
A: If Hoid knows?
Q: Yeah.
A: Hoid did not take it, but I’m not answering whether he knows.Q: When spren die, they kind of become part of everything, so why did, when the Knights broke their oaths, why did they stay as Shardblades?
A: They had been bound into that form by those oaths. The oaths are broken, but it’s like they’re cracked. Does that make sense? Like, there’s still something holding those spren and that’s what made them [?] It would have been better if they had actually died, does that make sense? But they couldn’t, they’re bound in that form.Q: But their consciousness is gone-?
A: They still have a consciousness some- to an extent.
Q: That’s why the screaming happens.
A: Yes.
[35:28]
Q: So Words of Radiance… [paper crumpling; Adolin?] ...killed by… [crumpling; Sadeas?] … knife through the eye [crumpling] … worked so hard, I mean like does that change him in any way [?]
A: You will have to read on and see where it goes, and it’s certainly not something his father would have done, but at the same time, ah, I think there is a legitimate moral argument that what he did was right. I think there’s a legitimate one. I’m not saying it won’t change him or stuff, but there is a legitimate argument.
[36:30]
Q: What has been your most favorite character arc to write?
A: Um… Normally it’s very hard to answer questions like this because it’s like all my characters are my favorites, but in this case I can say writing Perrin’s arc in the Wheel of Time was very satisfying and fulfilling since I’ve been a fan for so many years and being able to do the things there, yeah. That was very satisfying, how about that?
[37:05]
Q: So I thought through a lot of your recommendations, and a lot of other recommendations from other people on reddit, but where do you find books that you read?
A: Reads the first few pages to his wife, who’s a avid reader. Guy Gavriel Kay, Brian McClellan, Elerix [?] David Gemmell.
38:40
Q: For the past year I’ve been the administrator for the Stormlight Archive Wiki and any feedback you or Peter could give me is most welcome, no feedback would be fine,-
A: I go there when I’m looking for, like that, like, I know I wrote something about this, what did I put in the book. Then I’ll go to your wiki and look at it.
Q: That’s cool.
A: I got that habit with the Wheel of Time, because I could find it in the notes, but it always takes longer to go to the notes than to Google and Google doesn’t index my wiki, so I go to yours. I think it’s well done. More stuff about the SA wiki and maybe they’ll link it on Brandon’s website.
40:20ish
Q: I’m at a magazine and we were wondering if you could do an interview or a short story.
A: I can do the interview, but I don’t do short short stories, short means 17,000 words for me.
[41:13]
Q: When it comes to like, touring and stuff like that, how do you pick these locations?
A: Sometimes, it’s my publisher, sometimes it’s me saying let’s go somewhere different. And sometimes it’s places where I’ve come a lot where they do a good job, like when I come to a store like this, I think they do a good job, so I put a good report into the publisher and say, feel free to send me back to that store.
Q: I’m a student at San Francisco University, and I have a lot of people who are fans of you there and they would love it if [?]
A: The best way to get me to places like that is if you have a local science fiction convention. If you have them invite me as the guest of honor, I do that sort of a lot, like I do [VegCon?]
Q: I’m planning on going to [VegCon? WorldCon?], so-
A: Cool! Something about the Hugo’s? It’s a civic responsibility if you’re going to WorldCon.
Q: Well, I feel like-
A: I’m not saying you have to vote for me, just saying that you have to vote.
Q: I’m concerned that that bloodthirsty sword is off on his own again
A: He, ah, he is, he is in dangerous hands right now, let’s just say that
Q: Yeah, untrustworthy hands.
A: Yes, yes he is.
[43:14]
Q: Does Sazed talk to Wax when he has that thing in his ear, when he’s praying?
A: Um, yes.
Q: Aha! Yes! Uh, ok, second thing. My brother and I have been debating about Hoid and how he got his abilities. We have a couple theories. One of them is Hemalurgy.
A: Ok…
Q: The other has to do with the portals into the worlds themselves, because the birds in Sixth of Dusk-
A: Ok, he does not have Hemalurgy. He has powers that predate the Shattering of Adonalsium. Not all of his powers predate, but he does have powers that predate.
Q: Ok, so I was wrong on both counts then… Am I wrong on both counts?
A: I’m not saying that. I’m saying that he has powers that predate, and has gained powers since.
[44:51]
Q: I actually have a few questions. I figure most of them will be RAFO, but I might as well try. In [shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell], that one? The Evil that destroyed the Homeland, was that Odium [killing?] a Shard? Or was that someone else-
A: RAFO
Q: Are we going to see more of that world?
A: Yes.
Q: Sweet!
A: Thredony is the name of that world.
Q: I’ll make sure to write that down somewhere. I really liked Silence, by the way. She was awesome. Are we going to find out who brought Nightblood to Roshar?
A: Yes.Q: Cool. I’m not going to bother asking who did right now. With Syl being able to be revived, is Adolin ever going to be able to revive his own blade, or-
A: Ah, that would be very difficult, as the orig-, in most cases, the original person who broke the oaths has to be the one.
Q: Ok. Do you have to have done the third oath before you can convert your spren into a Blade?
A: Uh, in most orders, yes.
Q: What about Shallan then? Did she do it, cause she was a kid when she first-
A: Um… You will find out more.
Q: Cool. The other big one that I had was, um, how far ahead in the timeline is Sixth of Dusk?
A: Pretty far.
Q: … kind of a general-
A: Most people that I’m writing about now are all dead.
Q: Is it up into the third trilogy of Mistborn?
A: It is that era, yes.
Q: Sweet! That’s what I thought.
A: It might be a little bit before that trilogy, but it’s that era.
Q: I have a final question then, is there a Hoid cameo in Shadows for Silence?
A: I intentionally didn’t put one in, because I didn’t- couldn't come- there was no reason for him to be there, and I didn’t want to be doing it just to do it, if that makes sense, like, the Cosmere isn’t just a bunch of cameos, it is a story within itself.
[47:05]
Q: One thing I wanted to ask about is the [test?] on Emperor’s Soul, are you going to write a bigger one about that?
A: It’s unlikely because I think it works so well as it is. But you will probably see Shai again at some point.
[49:20]
Discussion of Taiwan. The Emperor’s Soul was inspired by his visit to the National Palace.
[51:15]
Q: Do you ever feel that when you are writing becomes forced and what do you do…[?]
A: I write it even when it’s feeling forced when read it over the next day and see if it reads forced.
[53:30]
[someone’s phone disappeared
][56:00]
Apple employee and they discuss collaboration between Tor and iBooks Store and how someone there must be a fan of Brandon’s b/c they are very accommodating
[The phone reappears!]
[57:20]
Q: My son wants to know...Why is Alcatraz a bad guy but he doesn’t do bad things?
A: He ahm...You can just say to him that Alcatraz is not a bad guy but he has a poor opinion of himself. He has bad self esteem.
[59:35]
Q: Who is your favorite Epic?
A: I would say that Megan is my favorite Epic.
[1:00:00]
Discussion of reading long series, WoT, having too many books on your list, etc
[1:02:05]
Q: What’s Mitosis? Is it available in print?
A: Novelette. They will reprint it. It’s too expensive now.
[1:03:30]
Q: Were you ah, [?] dictionary type thing with Jordan and Harriet? (maybe about getting it signed)
A: I have not done very much of that. It was supposed to be Harriet’s thing. But she won’t tour again.
[1:05:05]
Q: Are you going to complete any series or just continue? (
)A: I will be completing stuff. The Reckoners will be finished fairly soon. I writing the last one right now.
Q: And new Mistborn?
A: And the new Mistborns. We are getting close to the end of that.
[1:05:38]
Q: Why can you never find the fourth book in the Alcatraz series?
A: Because the fourth book had the lowest distribution and was not printed in paperback. And so.. but the reprints of those -- the new ones that Tor is doing -- I’ve seen the covers and they’re awesome. They’re the first time I’ve gotten good covers on an Alcatraz book. So I’m very excited about those.
Q: You did like [name]’s covers?
A: No I thought they were terrible. The first one wasn’t bad. I was ok with the first one. But they got progressively worse I felt.
[1:06:54]
Q: What book has inspired you the most?
A: Les Miserables. I love Victor Hugo’s writing style. His use of character and his use of language.
[1:08:00]
Discussion of Clayton’s bookstore and comedy in Warbreaker. “I feel that a great book is going to have a wide range of emotions. And so I try to stick various different ones in.”
[1:11:20]
Discussion of Saudi Arabia and how he’s going to UAE this summer.
[1:12:50]
Q: What influenced your characters in Steelheart? Comic books? Specific ones?
A: I’ve read a lot of comics. Watchman influences everyone. Kingdom Come - one of first that really made me think about comics. The original Turtles. Graphic novels (self contained) like the Killing Joke.
[1:13:35]
Q: From the very beginning did you already know like the Cosmere? Like was that your goal setting out?
A: It was my goal very early on. In fact, before I wrote any books I wrote a short story about Hoid. So he goes back to before the very first book that I wrote. So yeah it goes back pretty far. I can trace inspirations back to Asimov tying Foundation and Robots together and feeling like that was really cool and wanting to do something like that, if it makes sense. And so I would say that’s probably like the first seed was when I read the later Foundation books and they tied them together.
[1:14:35]
Q: What books you use to improve your own writing?
A: Orson Scott Card’s books. Stephen King’s book is very good. Improves more when I read writing I admire and ask myself what they did well. Anne McCaffery for example.
[1:15:35]
Discussion of Brandon’s comments on perfectionism and creativity.
[1:16:38]
How’d you get the idea for Steelheart?
[1:18:43]
Q: I was reading stuff online about like a Mistborn videogame…
A: Yeah, we’ll still working on it. It’s taking much longer than we thought. The developer the producer of the game and I had chosen -- they, ah, had a falling out and split and so we had to start over from scratch and that’s what really threw us for a loop. We then took it to a really prestigious one game company that I love and they considered it for a long time, but it turned out that they just didn’t have the time and couldn’t do it. So now we are kind of back to square one finding a third group to do it.
[1:19:20]
Discussion of touring to Turkey. (It’s a bit far) He’ll eventually be touring the UAE (sometime this year?)
[1:19:48]
Q: My question was about Shards actually. So at the end of Words of Radiance Syl is turning into a Shardblade as well as other different weapons. And Kaladin has a whole bunch of Windspren around him. And I am wondering if that is a precursor to Shardplate?
A: I think you are a very smart man and you are asking wise questions.
[1:24:25]
Q: I’ve been trying to figure out how to make an Alethi dress without making the safehand pouch look lumpy.
A: People online have done it. Make it tighter. Also it looks natural in-world.
Q: I had a question about how the Alethi women exhibit their wealth through their dresses. So I know there’s embroidery in the fabric [that your’re kinda disabling one arm?]
A: So the gemstones -- like well cut gemstones and then fill them with Stormlight. The glowing is how they’d shown off their wealth.
Q: What kind of embroidery is it? Flowers? Patterns?
A: It is a lot of things but the Alethi’s don’t do the flower thing....It’s not really an Alethi thing. So you are seeing a lot of designs and hatchings. They may look a little Arabic to you. Or the glyphs and things like that you will see worked in but very stylized.
[1:26:26]
Q: Worldbringers and Worldsingers -- similar mission?
A: The similarity of the names is intentional.
Q: Similar origin?
A: Yes.
Q: Did Hoid start them?
A: That’s a RAFO. That’s a RAFO, but definitely they have a similar origin.
[1:27:00]
Q: Do you always stick to your outline?
A: I do not. I will rebuild my outline. If I think I’m gonna break it, I’ll try a chapter that direction and if it works rewrite the outline.
Q: Do you ever refer back to your previous book …?
A: Definitely. Usually I make an outline for the first book, write it, then outline the series.
[1:28:15]
Who’s fav Epic? Megan.
[1:29:35]
Q: What’s the secret to getting books out as fast as you do?
A: The secret is my work ethic. Pioneer work ethic. Pat is a perfectionist. I get it pretty good and hand it to my editor to polish. His biggest strength over me is his lyrical prose. That extra 1% takes him two years. I love what I do and I write every day.
[1:31:35]
Q: If you electrified metal would that have any impact on being able to Steelpush or Ironpull it?
A: I do not currently have that as an effect. That interfering with it requires Investiture. And electrifying is not Investiture. So no it would not. In fact, I’m absolutely sure it will not because the plans call for that to be a possibility they are doing in the future.
Q: Can a kandra burn things...could they burn lerasium...and if they did would they be able to burn other things?
A: Yes that is possible. It is even plausible that an kandra could gain other powers, they just don’t know how to do it.
Raw audio: soundcloud
Edit: Added link to raw audio in case someone want to look up something or double check.
7 -
It interesting that you felt that way Kurkistan, because I actually hated Sadeas more at the end of WoK. The chapters from Sadeas' PoV in WoR really helped me understand his philosophy and how he rationalized his actions. I didn't like him, but I think maybe it made him seem, to me, like a product of his nation and times.
Finished transcribing. There was someone else, I thought, recording the line so they may have the second half. I'm sticking a few highlights in a spoiler tag below. Italicized lines = paraphrased vs. text = verbatim.
Hope to see some of you at the next one of these. Maybe we should have a pre-signing thread too next time to coordinate a meetup?
[7:45]
Q: If your character Hoid were a Planeswalker what color would he be?
A: You know I might do him like the Reaper King. Like two slash on all five. That’s what I would do him as.[17:47]Q: Will you tell us the Intent of Bavadin’s Shard?A: The Intent of Bavadin’s Shard? No. But good question. Have a RAFO card.[19:07]Q: Syl changes forms a lot more than the other bonded spren. Is human her default?A: Is Syl’s default form the little human woman or does she not really have one? You will find out more about that eventually.[32:14]Q: The Shardblade that Dalinar had at the end of Words of Radiance, was that the Honorblade?A: The Shardblade that Dalinar had at the end of Words of Radiance that he gave up?Q: Yeah, that he gave up.A: No it was not.Q: It was not? So what happened to the Honorblade that the Herald had?A: Nobody kno- Well, somebody knows, but it is not known to the main characters.Q: Can I ask if uh, Hoid-A: If Hoid knows?Q: Yeah.A: Hoid did not take it, but I’m not answering whether he knows.Q: When spren die, they kind of become part of everything, so why did, when the Knights broke their oaths, why did they stay as Shardblades?A: They had been bound into that form by those oaths. The oaths are broken, but it’s like they’re cracked. Does that make sense? Like, there’s still something holding those spren and that’s what made them [?] It would have been better if they had actually died, does that make sense? But they couldn’t, they’re bound in that form.Q: But their consciousness is gone-?A: They still have a consciousness some- to an extent.Q: That’s why the screaming happens.A: Yes.[35:28]Q: So Words of Radiance… [paper crumpling; Adolin?] ...killed by… [crumpling; Sadeas?] … knife through the eye [crumpling] … worked so hard, I mean like does that change him in any way [?]A: You will have to read on and see where it goes, and it’s certainly not something his father would have done, but at the same time, ah, I think there is a legitimate moral argument that what he did was right. I think there’s a legitimate one. I’m not saying it won’t change him or stuff, but there is a legitimate argument.[43:14]Q: Does Sazed talk to Wax when he has that thing in his ear, when he’s praying?A: Um, yes.Q: Aha! Yes! Uh, ok, second thing. My brother and I have been debating about Hoid and how he got his abilities. We have a couple theories. One of them is Hemalurgy.A: Ok…Q: The other has to do with the portals into the worlds themselves, because the birds in Sixth of Dusk-A: Ok, he does not have Hemalurgy. He has powers that predate the Shattering of Adonalsium. Not all of his powers predate, but he does have powers that predate.Q: Ok, so I was wrong on both counts then… Am I wrong on both counts?A: I’m not saying that. I’m saying that he has powers that predate, and has gained powers since.[44:51]Q: I actually have a few questions. I figure most of them will be RAFO, but I might as well try. In [shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell], that one? The Evil that destroyed the Homeland, was that Odium [killing?] a Shard? Or was that someone else-A: RAFOQ: Are we going to see more of that world?A: Yes.Q: Sweet!A: Thredony is the name of that world.Q: I’ll make sure to write that down somewhere. I really liked Silence, by the way. She was awesome. Are we going to find out who brought Nightblood to Roshar?A: Yes.Q: Cool. I’m not going to bother asking who did right now. With Syl being able to be revived, is Adolin ever going to be able to revive his own blade, or-A: Ah, that would be very difficult, as the orig-, in most cases, the original person who broke the oaths has to be the one.Q: Ok. Do you have to have done the third oath before you can convert your spren into a Blade?A: Uh, in most orders, yes.Q: What about Shallan then? Did she do it, cause she was a kid when she first-A: Um… You will find out more.Q: Cool. The other big one that I had was, um, how far ahead in the timeline is Sixth of Dusk?A: Pretty far.Q: … kind of a general-A: Most people that I’m writing about now are all dead.Q: Is it up into the third trilogy of Mistborn?A: It is that era, yes.Q: Sweet! That’s what I thought.A: It might be a little bit before that trilogy, but it’s that era.Q: I have a final question then, is there a Hoid cameo in Shadows for Silence?A: I intentionally didn’t put one in, because I didn’t- couldn't come- there was no reason for him to be there, and I didn’t want to be doing it just to do it, if that makes sense, like, the Cosmere isn’t just a bunch of cameos, it is a story within itself.[57:20]Q: My son wants to know...Why is Alcatraz a bad guy but he doesn’t do bad things?A: He ahm...You can just say to him that Alcatraz is not a bad guy but he has a poor opinion of himself. He has bad self esteem.[59:35]Q: Who is your favorite Epic?A: I would say that Megan is my favorite Epic.[1:05:38]Q: Why can you never find the fourth book in the Alcatraz series?A: Because the fourth book had the lowest distribution and was not printed in paperback. And so.. but the reprints of those -- the new ones that Tor is doing -- I’ve seen the covers and they’re awesome. They’re the first time I’ve gotten good covers on an Alcatraz book. So I’m very excited about those.Q: You did like [name]’s covers?A: No I thought they were terrible. The first one wasn’t bad. I was ok with the first one. But they got progressively worse I felt.[1:06:54]Q: What book has inspired you the most?A: Les Miserables. I love Victor Hugo’s writing style. His use of character and his use of language.[1:13:35]Q: From the very beginning did you already know like the Cosmere? Like was that your goal setting out?A: It was my goal very early on. In fact, before I wrote any books I wrote a short story about Hoid. So he goes back to before the very first book that I wrote. So yeah it goes back pretty far. I can trace inspirations back to Asimov tying Foundation and Robots together and feeling like that was really cool and wanting to do something like that, if it makes sense. And so I would say that’s probably like the first seed was when I read the later Foundation books and they tied them together.[1:18:43]Q: I was reading stuff online about like a Mistborn videogame…A: Yeah, we’ll still working on it. It’s taking much longer than we thought. The developer the producer of the game and I had chosen -- they, ah, had a falling out and split and so we had to start over from scratch and that’s what really threw us for a loop. We then took it to a really prestigious one game company that I love and they considered it for a long time, but it turned out that they just didn’t have the time and couldn’t do it. So now we are kind of back to square one finding a third group to do it.[1:19:48]Q: My question was about Shards actually. So at the end of Words of Radiance Syl is turning into a Shardblade as well as other different weapons. And Kaladin has a whole bunch of Windspren around him. And I am wondering if that is a precursor to Shardplate?A: I think you are a very smart man and you are asking wise questions.[1:26:26]Q: Worldbringers and Worldsingers -- similar mission?A: The similarity of the names is intentional.Q: Similar origin?A: Yes.Q: Did Hoid start them?A: That’s a RAFO. That’s a RAFO, but definitely they have a similar origin.[1:31:35]Q: If you electrified metal would that have any impact on being able to Steelpush or Ironpull it?A: I do not currently have that as an effect. That interfering with it requires Investiture. And electrifying is not Investiture. So no it would not. In fact, I’m absolutely sure it will not because the plans call for that to be a possibility they are doing in the future.Q: Can a kandra burn things...could they burn lerasium...and if they did would they be able to burn other things?A: Yes that is possible. It is even plausible that an kandra could gain other powers, they just don’t know how to do it.Edit: typos
13 -
Thanks Curiosity! Looks great to me. I was mostly trying to get an outline of the signing with paraphrased questions and answers unless it is a potentially Cosmere-impacting answer. You did an awesome job.
I got in the signing line during the reading, which is why that fades out near the middle. I assume we have the reading already because it's the same one he's been doing at most of the signings.
0 -
Audio: soundcloud
Beginnings of a transcription: https://docs.google.com/document/d/16_wtZtrjkDjmdcq1qhOBh8WTzXmO7ZHP15Zzo4Q0JMs/edit?usp=sharing
Edit: Fixed soundcloud link.
4 -
I recorded parts of the Q&A and the first half of the signing line. I'm working on transcribing, but in the mean time I wanted to mention one cool tidbit from Brandon. He's (re)optioned 4 of his books/series to be made into movies: Steelheart, Legion, Mistborn, Emperors Soul. I didn't record his answer, but he said that Steelheart was optioned on Friday, that Emperor's Soul was optioned by DMG (Iron Man 3), and that there is a film treatment (between scene cards and a screenplay) for Mistborn. If I recall, he said the DMG guys went down the Cosmere rabbit hole and got excited. He made a joke about them playing with the idea of a "Sanderson Cinematic Universe"
10 -
This is very cool! Looks amazing Geekritique.
I wanted to share one tidbit from a question I asked at the Steelheart signing way back. Turns out Taldain is tidally locked with it's sun which is why it is always day on one side and night on the other. Doesn't change your map, but I thought it was a cool stray piece of cosmological info.
1 -
Hey OP,
Avatar: The Last Airbender - I'd second this one. It's a lovely show full of character growth, friendships, action and fun.
Friday Night Lights - This may not be everyone's cup of tea, but I really thought it was an incredible series. Focuses on the lives of a Texas high school football coach, his family, and a few football players and other teenagers. Exceptional drama. The first episode just sucked me right in.
Sherlock - By some of the Doctor Who guys (in case you haven't seen it yet).
Legend of the Seeker - Fun, pulpy series based on the Sword of Truth novels. By the Xena people.
The West Wing - Office drama set in the White House. Thought provoking and engaging.
Top Gear? - Just discovered this. Loads of fun.
1 -
I like this theory, but I'm having a hard time trying to fit stormspren into it. So far as we know (or think we know), the red lightening stormspren are the only definitive Odiumspren we have seen.
Are storms then a sensation or a force? Or are they not actually stormspren but something else like destruction/"wind blowing really hard" spren? Or maybe some combination of force/sensation like Moogle theorizes?
0 -
What I find interesting is the mention of Rayse being "what we made him":
"He is what we made him to be, old friend. And that is what he, unfortunately, wished to become." - The Reply
Does this imply that the shardholders/Hoid were to blame for the shattering of Adonalsium? That it wasn't a mistake but rather that they chose it and the specific shards they now hold?
---
The writer of the reply certainly implies that he believes there to be a grand plan to the direction of the Cosmere. I wonder what makes him believe so?
Why "design of Adonalsium"? If it is shattered, how can it be designing anything?"The worlds you now tread bear the touch and design of Adonalsium. Our interference so far has brought nothing but pain."
...
"However, it seems to me that all things have been set up for a purpose, and if we--as infants--stumble thought the workshop, we risk exacerbating, not preventing, a problem."
---
Also, any thoughts on what "the gemstone" is and how it can be "dead"? Argent, I believe, asked if it was the sphere Gavilar gives to Szeth and got a RAFO. My mind is crazily imagining it to be the cognitive aspect of something that is "dead" and has somehow been pulled into the physical realm (in a way opposite to Jasnah elsecalling her physical body into Shadesmar).
*Edited for weird spacing
0 -
Yup she is in White Sand. I hope you enjoy it RShara!
Further discussion of Khriss here (and Peter chimes in): http://www.17thshard.com/forum/topic/6803-who-is-khriss/
0 -
Hum, well Khriss is definitely a human woman (from White Sand) and not a shardholder so far as I know. Although, she doesn't exhibit much Cosmere awareness in that book, so something must change about her. She is something of a scholar.
I doubt that she is the writer of the reply as I can't imagine how she is an "old friend" of Hoid's. She is not Yolish.
0 -
They are in fact.
He also uses them for Kaladin. I'm not sure if any of this is significant, but what saying oaths and "leveling up" as a Surgebinder has to do with "Inspiration" I really don't know.
"THE WORDS ARE ACCEPTED, the Stormfather said reluctantly." - WoR chapter 84, towards the end
0 -
Here's my long shot theory. The imprisoned Taln is a kandra!
Oooh I like it
. Or maybe Shai Forged Taln onto another body.1 -
The "These words are accepted" seems to be a pretty common thing that he's been putting in a lot of books he is signing, I'm not sure there is any hidden meaning/context to it.
IDK WeiryWriter, in SF someone asked him about the moment that Kaladin made his different decision in WoK Prime and he didn't hear the question correctly...
Q: So what was the Moment?
A: It was actually right near the climax. It was the phrase 'These words are accepted.'... Oh I thought you were talking about the Moment of Inspiration. Oh the moment you're asking about is the moment where Kaladin, in the original writing, he took the Blade and plate instead of turning it down.
I also noticed that in chapter 32 when Kaladin is riding the highstorm there is an odd quote:
"He soared, alive with lightening, his flashes of inspiration." - WoR chapter 32 The One Who Hates; right near the beginning
I feel there must be something here we are missing.
0 -
So we're looking at Soothing or Rioting; I'm guessing Soothing from what I remember of the scene. Or some other weird esoteric alloy we've never seen.
Q: What alloy did Hoid drink?
A: He wanted to make people act in the way he wanted them to
Interesting. I thought he was burning Tin as Hoid is up on a tree limb outside Shallan's carriage but can quote back to Shallan what her brother said:
"Your father is slowly destroying your family," the messenger said. "Your brother was right on that count. He was wrong about everything else." - WoR end of chapter 45 Middlefest
Either way, allomancy and feruchemy are both proven!
0 -
Great thanks RShara! I was definitely paraphrasing answers and leaving out ones that I thought had been previously answered or were not Cosmere-significant.
Will do better next time. I think I actually enjoy transcribing. It's definitely helping my typing speed
.0 -
Yes of course. Here's everything in the second audio clip for searching purposes (in a spoiler tag so the thread doesn't explode):
4:25 - Will book 5 be last Alcatraz book?
A: Yes.
5:10 - Who are the 5 main characters from the first half of the SA?
A: Kaladin, Shallan, Szeth, Eshonai, Dalinar in that order
7:40 - When are we going to get Hoid’s book?
A: Hoid has 6 books, they are the 3 books of Dragonsteel and the last Mistborn trilogy of the nine book arc.
10:00 - What magics does Hoid have?
A: So far on screen we have seen him use three of the different magics. You know at least two of them. More obvious clues are in this book. Watch where he and Kaladin have some interactions. You’ve already seen him and Shallan in her flashback - in that scene he uses one if you watch.
20:20 - Some question about Gaz; can’t hear it
A: Gaz was always planned to come back. Having characters disappear and come back is something he likes about Robert Jordan.
22:00 - Some question about how [Hoid?] travels between worlds
A: “There is a big clue in this book. There is a very big clue in the very first book I published.”
23:00 - Do you hear the Parshendi song as you write it?
A: Yes, but if he ever created it, he’d have someone more musically inclined do it.
23:30 - Question about an Emperor’s Soul sequel
A: “The first one turned out so well I don’t want to spoil it by doing anything more….If I don’t do anything more I’m sure Shai will worm her way into some other story.”
25:20 - If something happened to GRRM would you want to take that over?
A: No, you’d want someone who is a better match to him. Joe Abercrombie.
27:15 - Any plans to write SciFi?
A: Yes, but it’ll be in the cosmere after the technology has caught up to SciFi. The next Mistborn trilogy will be about 1980s technology and then the last a space opera.
32:30 - Are you going to expand on the Cosmere in its own book? When will it come to the forefront?
A: Yes, Dragonsteel and third Mistborn trilogy will be more about the Cosmere. Wants to warn people when they need to understand all this info.
37:35 - What was Kaladin’s original decision that you changed?
A: Kaladin won the Plate and Blade in chapter one and kept it. Will release as a free download on website.
39:50 - How long did it take you to perfect your signature?
A: Has evolved from a B and an S into the swirling thing it is now. Can find old signature in old Elantris books.
42:25 - How did you decide that you were going to tackle racism, gender, classism in WoK?
A: “One of the things I like about Fantasy is the ability to tackle things like this in a way that removes the baggage from our current society which is why you see me doing things like the gender relations centered around whether the hand is sleeved or not. I want to do something that is one step removed so that it is pertinent…The Parshendi-Human thing is going to be a big deal for the series so I wanted to introduce it early on in the books.”
49:00 - What’s your favorite SciFi series?
A: Vernor Vinge’s Deepness in the Sky/Fire Upon the Deep.
51:50 - Books recommendations?
A: Vernor Vinge, Guy Gavriel Kay (Tigana), Pratchett, NK Jamison (A Hundred Thousand Kingdoms)
1:04:50 - Would aluminum give an Atium shadow?
A: No, if you threw an aluminum spear it would not give an Atium shadow.
1:05:05 - How long have you been planning for Vasher to be in WoR?
A: “Vasher was in the 2002 WoK by name. I only changed him to the new name after I’d finished this entire draft because I’m like ‘Oh he’d probably go under a pseudonym’...Vasher was much bigger then b/c Kaladin took the Plate and Blade and Vasher was his teacher.”
1:07:30 - Question about new (non-sequel) books?
A: “I’ve been developing a world for a while now where - are you familiar with Tesla, he wanted this whole wireless electricity thing. It was kinda like electrifying the air and having the current run into the ground. I want to build a world where that happens naturally. Where your ground is positive and your air is negative and electrons will move through it and animals adapt to use this and you can like set a lamp on the ground and it’ll just glow because of the current running through it...I just have to do a lot more research on electricity than I’ve done now.”
1:11:10 - Question about Ars Arcanum?
A: It’s not Hoid. IDK if I’ve released who it is; but its probably not who people are thinking but it is in-world.
1:13:00 - Question that I couldn’t hear. Sounds like “What was the [...]”?
A: “It was actually right near the climax. It was the phrase ‘These words are accepted.’... Oh I thought you were talking about the Moment of Inspiration.”
1:16:00 - Why was Jasnah’s death glossed over?
A: Because that was not going to happen in this book and Shallan was unable to come into her own.
1:17:25 - What’s your favorite original Shardholder? (Props to bartbug for this question)
A: I don’t know...The tricky thing is that I’m going to have to write them as their personalities because right now they are just concepts. I’m very fond of Bavadin but I can’t say.
1:18:00 - Is Bavadin the only shard on Taldain?
A: He is the only shard on the planet. (is he the sun?) - RAFO
1:18:25 - Can Hemalurgy take a surge or a spren bond?
A: Hemalurgy can interact with every magic. It is very important to the Cosmere and its invention is “a thing of great power and great danger”.
1:18:50 - Have people not from/on Scadrial used Hemalurgy?
A: Yes.
1:19:10 - What was the pouch on the Radiant in Dalinar’s vision in WoR?
A: RAFO. I'm not saying its important, but you have to get a RAFO.
1:19:30 - Were there spren bonds before Aharietiam?
A: RAFO. The spren were around back then; they weren’t what they are now. They’ve changed over the course of the book. As sharders have figured out, they are much more prevalent following what happened to Honor. There were some spren on the planet before even that happened.
1:20:30 - Are there other shards in the Taldain solar system?
A: Now that’s a clever question. There is only one for that solar system. There are other places with only one. It’s not uncommon. We’ve gone to places with more than one because that is where the conflict is Cosmere centric.
1:22:10 - What was Jasnah’s last thought?
A: Her last thoughts were of escaping.
1:32:00 - Is Jasnah’s going to be one of the backstories?
A: It is. She’s on the back five.
1:32:30 - Is the sword Nightblood?
A: Yes. Warbreaker was Zahel’s backstory.
1:39:15 - Do all the humans have innate Investiture?
A: I believe that they all do. Drabs don’t. You haven’t see any yet that don’t have innate Investiture.
1:50:00 - What’s the deal with safehands?
A: You’ll find out eventually. There is something it originated in. Inspired by bottoms of feet being offensive in Korea.
1:59:00 - Why do they ride horses instead of fast insects of some sort?
A: RAFO.
2:00:15 - At the very end of WoR, Dalinar touches a Shardblade and it screams at him. Should that particular Blade have been safe?
A: No it should not have. It's a clue that something has happened. There are other clues that something is wrong with what the story you've been told is.
2:01:00 - Did Hoid switch out the blades?
A: Hoid did not switch out the blades, but good question.
2:14:15 - Does the Silence Divine take place in the Cosmere?
A: It does, it takes place on a planet called Thredony. There is no shard on that planet however. The magic is more something you interact with, not something you perform b/c there isn’t a shard there.
2:14:50 - If Kelsier’s Cognitive Shadow or a Seon went to the forests of calamity, would they be shades?
A: Yes, that is the same thing. The people on that planet; their Investiture; the lack of shard means that their cognitive shadows react differently. The ghost of Leras is the same thing too.
2:15:00 - Is Nightblood was on Roshar would it be a shardblade?
A: Yes, they are exactly the same thing. He is a shardblade that is twisted and is a lot more powerful than normal.
4 -
Transcription done! https://docs.google.com/document/d/1GOxewGM-E40JBs4EELEeQz7wXubJfP4oyfhkDNVgORU/edit?usp=sharing
Interesting answers (not already mentioned in this thread):
10:00 - What magics does Hoid have?A: So far on screen we have seen him use three of the different magics. You know at least two of them. More obvious clues are in this book. Watch where he and Kaladin have some interactions. You’ve already seen him and Shallan in her flashback - in that scene he uses one if you watch.22:00 - Some question about how [Hoid?] travels between worldsA: “There is a big clue in this book. There is a very big clue in the very first book I published.”42:25 - How did you decide that you were going to tackle racism, gender, classism in WoK?A: “…The Parshendi-Human thing is going to be a big deal for the series so I wanted to introduce it early on in the books.”1:11:10 - Question about Ars Arcanum?A: It’s not him. IDK if I’ve released who it is; but its probably not who people are thinking but it is in-world.1:13:00 - Question that I couldn’t hear. Sounds like “What was the [...]”?A: “It was actually right near the climax. It was the phrase ‘These words are accepted.’... Oh I thought you were talking about the Moment of Inspiration.”1:17:25 - What’s your favorite original Shardholder? (Props to bartbug for this question)A: I don’t know...The tricky thing is that I’m going to have to write them as their personalities because right now they are just concepts. I’m very fond of Bavadin but I can’t say.1:18:00 - Is Bavadin the only shard on Taldain?A: He is the only shard on the planet. (is he the sun?) - RAFO1:18:50 - Have people not from/on Scadrial used Hemalurgy?A: Yes.1:19:10 - What was the pouch on the Radiant in Dalinar’s vision in WoR?A: RAFO. I'm not saying its important, but you have to get a RAFO.1:19:30 - Were there spren bonds before Aharietiam?A: RAFO... There were some spren on the planet before whatever happened to Honor.1:20:30 - Are there other shards in the Taldain solar system?A: There is only one for that solar system.1:59:00 - Why do they ride horses instead of fast insects of some sort?A: RAFO.6 -
Hey bartbug! Awesome job. Much better than what I got from my dying cell phone.
Started transcribing/paraphrasing the Q&A and reading: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1GOxewGM-E40JBs4EELEeQz7wXubJfP4oyfhkDNVgORU/edit?usp=sharing
3 -
I like that idea Teccam.
I still think we need a place to keep track of what questions are unanswered and which are recently answered. I think a google doc will be fine for now, although I might code something up in the future. I've created one for our SF signing at least: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XKRXWDJ-D-7Vz2-lVNtdOz-Nmhx5JkkYnP4FLIHunqA/edit?usp=sharing
Please share the answers on the doc. And perhaps we should also "claim" questions so that we don't ask the same ones twice?
0 -
I'll be there!
For the Q&A, I've been thinking about creating a Google Doc or something to better organize the questions we would like to ask. Also to be a single place for Sharders to see recently asked and answered questions (so they don't ask the same one twice).
The "Ultimate List of Questions for Brandon" thread has become large and the answers are spread across Theoryland, individual threads, etc.
Thoughts? Is there already a place for this?
2 -
Hey Joe, this is wonderful! Soooo excited that The Emperor's soul won. With a physical copy I'd be able to lend it out to all of those friends I know would love Brandon's books. Thanks again.
0 -
A few books which really pulled my into fantasy that haven't been mentioned yet (or only glancingly) include the Dragonriders of Pern novels, The Dark is Rising series, The Giver, The Phantom Tollbooth and Heir Apparent.
I specifically remember Ender's Game and Dune as being SciFi revelations.
I also loved L'Engle's Time Quartet (Wrinkle in Time and its sequels). And, of course, I was too 11 when Harry Potter received his letter.
0

Shadows of Self signing report: San Jose/Menlo Park, CA
in Events and Signings
Posted
Hey all, I was the other person recording and completely forgot to post my audio and transcribe anything new. I caught a bit of the beginning of the signing line before Cosmologist reached the table. Awesome job Cosmologist on the recording and transcription! There wasn't really anything new in that extra bit, but I transcribed what was there and added it to the doc.
Signing Line:
Q&A and reading:
The reading is included in this audio, but since it is up on tor.com I think it's ok to post it:
[00:01:45] His experience signing in the UAE
[00:06:20] Korean language
[00:14:35] Geek shaming
[00:20:15] Q&A
[00:20:55] How did the idea to have a cross-dressing female character come about?
[00:23:15] Mistborn video game?
[00:24:05] Where did the name Bridge Four come from?
[00:25:45] Career a straight line?
[00:28:40] Favorite and best character?
[00:29:50] Is the blank page terrifying?
[00:31:40] What's Adonalsium and do you intend to use him in a later book?
[00:32:45] Do you feel like the book is spoiled when Tor puts so much of it up online beforehand?
[00:34:45] How to network as a new author?
[00:37:50] Would you finish Kingkiller Chronicles if Pat dropped dead tomorrow? (interesting discussion of writing style)
[00:40:00] "My prose is much closer to George Martin's but my thematic content is *way* different. They say "Let's just give it to Sanderson." I'm like, "Really? Do you want all of these Game of Thrones people to stop swearing and get married?""
[00:40:40] Designing magic systems?
[00:41:25] Background of the Rosharan magic system?
[00:43:00] Working on another project; what makes you excited?
[00:44:55] Announcements
[00:45:20] There's a new scene in the 10th anniversary edition of Elantris that will be of interest to sharders
[00:49:20] When's Stormlight 3 come out? (Nov)
[00:49:47] What else do you have coming out?
[00:51:10] Will the Alcatraz cover be completely irrelevant to the content of the book?
[00:52:20] Reading