LadyCallista

I'm not sure how it's esoteric, lol, and I've heard of discord and I guess will have to figure out how that works. I miss just having a discussion on the actual site. Cause my question was about if breaking the oath of Unite would have broken that Bondsmith's oaths, since they basically genocided the singers instead of uniting them in a common cause. I had a thought on how that might have damaged the bond with the Sibling, since that's clearly not uniting ..

Thanks for the answer, although I'm apparently missing more than I realized, cause I never considered the Herald's insanity having an affect on the Sibling's Bondsmith abilities. I did consider this being something that had been discussed already, which is why I asked for a link about it, cause I did spend some time searching but nothing really seamed to match what I wanted to ask. Because where my mind went was well Bondsmiths Unite.... and could capturing BAM in a gemstone, severing the singers from their Connection, have broken Melishi's oaths to unite... and that's where the issues with the city started? Cause we know spren get weaker if bonds are broken...

Hi all, I'm new here but I've been reading Cosmere since Elantris, and need to bounce a theory off people. I recently took a deep dive into the wiki to get ready for WaT, and got stuck on wanting to know why the Sibling was so bitter towards humans, and towards her previous Bondsmith, Melishi. I have a few thoughts on this, and was wondering if someone could point me to a topic on it, as I'm sure I'm not the first to consider it. Or I'd love to start a chat on it here if people have thoughts.