Posted March 23 Good work elims, sorry village </3 For the record, my first post commenting on the elim team size was genuine - I hadn't checked my GM PM before posting that xD The Alpha+bloodsealing+crab legs accusation idea C1 was me trying to bring attention to Ash+bloodseal without being explicit about it, and I would've made the Alpha accusation had the new C2 clue not completely disproven the crab legs bit. The Archer+stone+bloodseal mix-up was intentional and I was waiting on confirmation from Araris about what would happen if I made an invalid accusation like that, but then Mat helpfully chimed in and pointed out my 'mistake' so I couldn't make that accusation anymore Archer is not elim btw. And then lastly I almost made that Mat+Bands+Rotspren accusation just to divert attention away from me but at that point I figured it'd be more suspicious if I didn't follow through on the chasmfiend idea. 0 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted March 23 So you’re saying I messed it up twice :| The other being when I didn’t guess the right thing before Stick did Three times if you count when I was the Assassin I wasn’t kidding when I said this wasn’t my type of game xD 0 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted March 23 (edited) 4 minutes ago, Matrim's Dice said: So you’re saying I messed it up twice :| The other being when I didn’t guess the right thing before Stick did Three times if you count when I was the Assassin I wasn’t kidding when I said this wasn’t my type of game xD Nah, I think I should’ve just been more low key Should’ve brought out Toucan for this. Edited March 23 by _Stick_ 0 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted March 23 Oh neat we didn't mix it up 29 minutes ago, _Stick_ said: Good work elims, sorry village </3 For the record, my first post commenting on the elim team size was genuine - I hadn't checked my GM PM before posting that xD The Alpha+bloodsealing+crab legs accusation idea C1 was me trying to bring attention to Ash+bloodseal without being explicit about it, and I would've made the Alpha accusation had the new C2 clue not completely disproven the crab legs bit. The Archer+stone+bloodseal mix-up was intentional and I was waiting on confirmation from Araris about what would happen if I made an invalid accusation like that, but then Mat helpfully chimed in and pointed out my 'mistake' so I couldn't make that accusation anymore Archer is not elim btw. And then lastly I almost made that Mat+Bands+Rotspren accusation just to divert attention away from me but at that point I figured it'd be more suspicious if I didn't follow through on the chasmfiend idea. We kind of picked up on the Bloodseal thing, but we were also hoping the group was too hung up on whether or not Chasmfiend should have been accident or not. Although honestly I didn't think Araris actually meant Skeletal for an Elderly so I was more confused 0 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted March 23 *HAPPY SCREAMING* FIRST GAME AND I WON WITH DA BOIS LEZ GO!!! 0 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted March 23 4 minutes ago, Telrao said: *HAPPY SCREAMING* FIRST GAME AND I WON WITH DA BOIS LEZ GO!!! It's fun to be evil your first game 0 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted March 23 Just now, The Wandering Wizard said: It's fun to be evil your first game It was very fun Kinda sad I couldn't kill anyone tho ehhehehe 0 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted March 23 Just now, Telrao said: It was very fun Kinda sad I couldn't kill anyone tho ehhehehe It's a pretty good environment to learn to be evil. Not much punishment for mistakes. Might even be good to since then people might guess you if you have similar clues to the assassin. 0 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted March 23 1 hour ago, _Stick_ said: Archer is not elim btw. I've never gotten to fake claim elim before, that was just trolling :D. Well played, elims. Guessing the person who got the right guess is apparently a foolproof strategy, so I commend you for not over thinking it. 1 minute ago, The Wandering Wizard said: It's a pretty good environment to learn to be evil. Not much punishment for mistakes. Might even be good to since then people might guess you if you have similar clues to the assassin. I didn't have any elim suspects this game, so you've got that going for you. Might have been eyeing Alpha actually. But point is you did well at going unnoticed 0 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted March 23 Whoa I missed so much. I had a busy day and wasn’t able to look at the game very much. I was Village the whole time guys. I’m not sure why I was kinda trying to make it seem like I was an elim… I gueas I’ll never know. 0 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted March 23 23 minutes ago, xinoehp512 said: ...well that was over fast. Imagine doing a QF65c for a tie breaker 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted March 23 2 hours ago, _Stick_ said: Nah, I think I should’ve just been more low key Should’ve brought out Toucan for this. Yes and no. I'd argue the issue with this format is that the Village especially if unlucky with tiles (imagine if we'd gotten a Time of Day tile instead) can often make a lot of really wrong guesses requiring nudges from the Witness. The secondary Elim wincon isn't so much a boon for them as a check on how much the Witness is allowed to feed the Village. Admittedly if they were going on an Accuser-is-the-Witness heuristic, it's possible to get burned, but given the last game, they were unlikely to not do it anyway. I would be sorry, but given my PoE was <Chasmfiend, Sandling, Nightmaw>, I wanted to hedge my bets against your being Evil and not burn my guess in case Chamsfiend was a scam, sorry not sorry 0 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
