Diego98

Yes, its Ati. He says that and goes on to the Beyond after dying.

Its almost the same. You cant breathe at high atmosphere. Not a Jedi, not a Sith. (Plo Koon maybe, and thats because of his race). And you cant ride those sheep-cow things in high atmosphere neither. The problem is that something really unique and powerful gets treated like the most common thing. Force healing, at least in Old Canon, has always been really hard to do. He was only mentioned once in movies (havent read those books, I just read the New Jedi Order saga) Thats it. Darth Plagueis. Not because of raw power. Because of knowing how to use it. Who trained Kylo? Another behind the scenes plot that doesnt get explained and we just gotta believe it? Yes, bringing people back from dead via Force was possible in the old canon. It was very hard to do. Why could Kylo do it? The special bond between him and Rey? What bond? Why is it there? Has it been explained? Luke and Leia were closer by blood and affections, yet they couldnt teleport objects between them. It is said in the movie that there are a hundred (or thousand, dont remember right) of those ships on Exogul. Fully crewed, functional and improved Death Stars. A hundred. A fricking hundred. Nor the Clone Wars Republic or the Empire at his full potencial had that weaponry. Palpatine was plotting to build the Death Star for decades. Now in 30 years he has at least 100 upgraded versions of that. Yeah, I get it. The tech was already discovered, so now its easier to replicate. But a hundred, by himself. No economic support from the Empire, or the First Order. And without anyone noticing it. And in a planet only a Lord Sith could ever find (or someone with that map thingy, but there are only two because ... Reasons). Can you imagine how many people its necessary to fully crew each of those ships? Not talking about material or resources. Just people. To build it, to crew it, to maintain it. How? How? The Old Canon had its plot holes and mistakes. Yes, Palpatine was back there too. But via cloning technology, not reviving because ... Who knows? (Gosh quoting a post in a mobile phone is HARD. Actually harder than force healing nowadays ...)

I think the movie was awful. Worst Star Wars movie by FAR. By the ending I was joking about "its not the worst, at least it didnt have ewooks", then, there they were. The plot is awful, the puns to Ryan Johnson are childlish and characters dont resonate at all. Firstmistake? Bring Palpatine back in the intro. No explanation, no surprise, anything. Just Palpatine is back cause I just read it. Then cut to Kylo Ren killing who knows who and who knows where to get an important artifact. Why was it there? Who were those aliens? Who knows and who cares! Surely Abrams didnt care. And thats just the beginning. I wont go through the entire movie, cause its too darn long. But I wanna point out a couple of issues: The Millenial Falcon opens its door in the middle of space and nothing happens. No special suits, no explanation, nothing. (When they rescue Rey from that First Order ship). Force healing? That thing that was so rare and hard to do that they trained special Jedi to do so? Lol, losers. Ask Rey, its easy peasy lemon squeezy now. Bringing people back from the death? Remember Darth Plagueis the Wise? He trained and trained and trained for years, and studied the Force for even more years. Now we have Kylo Ren who does it, again, easy peasy japaneasy. That Palpatine is not Palpatine. That Palpatine is your average action movie villain, not the mastermind behind the fall of the Republic and the Jedi. He doesnt feel like him. Now whit "The Final Order". I mean. How? "But how what?" HOW?. EVERYTHING. How can Palpatine in 30 years gather more fleet than the whole fricking Republic, the CoIS and the Empire together?! Not only the tech. The crew. The materials. The money. HOW COULD THEY EVEN BRING THOSE TO THAT LOST IN LEGEND SITH PLANET?!. But of course. Hundreds or thousands of hiper-advanced-DeathStars battleships need one tiny comm tower. Like, we have one of those in my neighborhood for wifi lol. Leia dies off cam sending an audio to his son. Really. Our Leia. I grew up with her. I defeated the Empire by her side. I even survived the fricking yuuzhan vong, with her. And you kill her like that. Really. I kinda liked The Force Awakens. I liked The Last Jedi. I hate The Rise of Skywalker. They didnt even showed the ghosts of our old characters ... Just voice. Really. They can bring back Harrison Ford for 2 minutes of screen, make a fully CGI Leia, but they cant show us the characters we love ... Awful, awful movie.

Vax has been bugging me since I first read it. Why would Ati think he is in Vax? Does Vax looks like Scadrial's CR? Or it was like a mind's allucination cause he just died? What do Ati and Leras have to do with Vax? Could it be a special place for all Vessels? Brandon refuses to say anything about it, so we can only wait.

Thats why all life on Roshar looks like acuatic. All fauna are related to some submarine animal: eels, crabs ... And the flora too, with coral-like plants. So it makes me wonder; were there vines on Roshar before Cultivation? Is the original purpose for which it was created still working? Or it was modified by the shards?

I couldn't find it. Brandon was asked about the voices and death rattles, and he said that there's something special going on with Rosharan dead. Its an old WoB. Now Im thinking that he meant Moelach.

When does he hear voices of dead people? And yet, we have that WoB saying that Rosharan dead are special ...

Yeah, but why does it only happens on Roshar? Vin killed a lot of people, yet she does not hear them ... It is confirmed that Rosharan dead are special, but why? Does it have to do with Adonalsium's plan for Roshar?

Then why does Dalinar and Szeth can hear voices from people who has passed to the Beyond? Its pretty clear when Dalinar hear Evi at the end of Oathbringer. I mean, maybe on Roshar there are "soul remains"? Cause there is something going on there ...

I was thinking about Roshar. We know that Adonalsium created Roshar for something. Maybe to storage investiture? Then I remembered a WoB I cant find right now, it would be nice if someone posted it here. Brandon was asked about the voices Dalinar and Szeth hear, the voices of the souls they killed. And Brandon said that there's something special going on with the dead on Roshar. What if Adonalsium created Roshar to be like a "souls cemetery", where souls that can not move on to the Beyond gathered? Or maybe other different soul thing? Its weird cause even Sazed mention that the Beyond is unrreachable, yet still Dalinar and Szeth and maybe others can here voices of people long dead.

Well, thats a tricky situation. I think it would be nice to have Venli cause all 10 books would refer to one Radiant in the Thaylen Field battle, but also it kinda could give a hint about the characters. I liked the idea of Eshonai's flashbacks with her being dead, cause it creates a sense of "danger" (that character will have a dedicated book, but that doesnt mean he will be alive). Plus, it would be kinda weird to give Eshonai the Oathbringer prologue not to give her more flashbacks ... I have faith in Sanderson and I know he will choose what fits best to the story.

In Magic The Gathering terms, Odium is Red, Honor is White and Cultivation is Green.

When Sanderson was signing here in Spain, I was able to ask him sonething that was bugging me about that scene. Later on, on Oathbringer, Odium says that he has been preparing Sadeas troops for quite a long time. I asked him if Odium had something to do with Sadeas murder, either controling bia thrill Adolin or using Sadeas. Ive got instanly RAFOed, so maybe it has some importance in the future.

I was rereading Elantris and saw that a few days ago. Its an expresion Kiin uses, like "for the Three Virgins!". It is never mentioned again, neither in book or in the Coppermind. I dont know. It stuck to me cause it was really odd and off place. Btw, Sel only has one moon, so that cant be.