DarthEllis

For the "what would endowment's description be like?" question I'd like to submit; She was a force that gave from an infinite well of power. A thread that started with the first aspect of life, and continued on until the end of all things. She was that which connected all things, the inheritance of the first ancestors to their very last descendants. She was the talent of a craftsman, the belief of a martyr, the knowledge of a genius, the wealth of a merchant, and the strength of a warrior, for she was every trait that was passed to an heir. She was passed from father to son, mother to daughter, teacher to student, mentor to protégé, since the beginning of mankind and until its end. She was the light that gave sight, the blood that gave life, and the air that gave Breath.

If the First Gem is a topaz (and not merely reminiscent of a topaz) do we believe any connection can be drawn from the Stormlight Archive where topaz is a polestone? So, do we think that the First Gem has anything to do with bone, stone, dependability, resourcefulness, or the number 9?

I don't remember that quote from Hoid, what were they talking about previously that prompted that statement? From what you said I think that Hoid was simply being self deprecating. It was already worthless because the gem was "dead," but it was "more" worthless because he was the one wearing it.

I think one thing to mention is that Sixth of the Dusk has had Herdazian food (and hates it.) This could mean that the type of food was brought by a worldhopper unrelated to the Ones Above, but it is more likely that this type of cuisine is something that the Ones Above introduced First of the Sun to. This leads me to be inclined that Rosharans are related to the Ones Above in some way. I think that with what we know of Era 4 Scadrial, that it is incredibly likely that the Ones Above utilize Scadrian technology, but perhaps it is a coalition of Scadrial and Roshar?

Do we have any idea what the First Gem is? I tried looking on the Coppermind and couldn't find anything substantial. This question specifically arises from the second of the Oathbringer Letters, where the author of the letter (Presumed to be Autonomy/Patji) addresses the receiver (Hoid) as "Bearer of the First Gem." If we then look at The Second Letter from Words of Radiance, we see that the author (Presumed to be Frost) asks the receiver (Hoid) whether he has "given up on the gemstone, now that it is dead?" I think it seems safe to say that both are referring to the same Gem. We also know that Hoid is known as Topaz, due to "the large gem stone he wore a long time ago." All of these seem to indicate that Hoid is carrying a gemstone, one that is known by those who were involved in the shattering of Adonalsium, and that it is important enough that once can address Hoid (who has many remarkable feats) simply by the fact that he is the bearer of this gem. The Gem is most likely as old as the shattering, or older. The Gem is either a topaz or of similar color and clarity, (I currently lean towards the latter) and is currently "dead." What constitutes the Gem being alive is unclear, although I would propose that the Gem is magical in nature, and so the gem's "death" is, at the very least, that the gem's magic is no longer active. It seems that Hoid is rather attached to the Gem, as he continues to carry it with him across worlds and through millennia, even though it is now dead. Not only is Hoid actively carrying the gem, but he seems to be actively trying to restore or use the gem, even though it is dead and individuals as knowledgeable as Frost believe that it is a lost cause. In fact, Frost's statement to Hoid that he should give up on the gemstone now that it is dead seems reminiscent to me of their interaction in The Traveler, where Frost tells Hoid, "You will not find a way to restore what you have lost...it is impossible." Hoid then responds to this stating that "You don't know that, the old rules no longer hold" and following up with "This isn't...just about the dead." This interaction, much like their discussion in the Words of Radiance letter, revolves around Hoid having something that is "dead" and Hoid not giving up on it. If we are to make this connection (which, admittedly, seems tenuous at best) we can then surmise that the gem's death is more than just a loss of power, and that the gem had some form of sentience or sapience, (as evidenced by the way Hoid responds to Frost) and Hoid is indeed actively trying to restore the gem to life. Lastly, I would propose that the First Gem was instrumental in the shattering of Adonalsium. Admittedly, this has no real evidence other than the fact that the other individuals involved in the shattering seem aware of the gem, and seem to have a measure of respect for the gem. I would however believe that from a writer's standpoint, referencing the first gem as an item from before the shattering does not seem to hold thematic weight unless it has an impact on the storyline from that time. I've looked a bit for references to the First Gem and haven't found anything more substantial than vague references. I'm hoping someone more knowledgeable will be able to fill me in.

So, how possible is it that the thing in The Traveler that Hoid was mentioned as trying to restore was the First Gem? In the Second Letter from Words of Radiance, (which is presumably from Frost to Hoid) Frost says "Have you given up on the gemstone, now that it is dead?" In the Second Oathbringer Letter the author (presumably Autonomy or one of his avatars) addresses the letter to "Cephandrius, bearer of the First Gem," (which we know from Secret History is one of Hoid's aliases) so I think we can assume that the gem Frost speaks of is this "First Gem." I feel like this theory is a little out there and I'm not sure how I feel about it, especially since I personally have no idea what the First Gem is, but I thought I'd attempt to talk about it...