QuantumSpren
Members-
Posts
56 -
Joined
-
Last visited
QuantumSpren's Achievements
30
Reputation
-
Tress of the Emerald Sea Reactions (No Cosmere)
QuantumSpren replied to Chaos's topic in Tress of the Emerald Sea
Well that was absolutely wonderful! I'd been in a Sanderson reading slump for a while but that really pulled me back in. I really couldn't stop smiling all the way through this book. -
So this is an interesting surprise! Thoughts?
-
QuantumSpren started following Lux
-
Brandon's Announcements
QuantumSpren replied to ProfessorMLyon's topic in General Brandon Discussion
I thought that this was a very late April fools joke at first. -
Yeah the golden light and the talk about a dawnshard being a command really makes me think that Dalinar must be a dawnshard with the UNITE command. I think that he somehow received it through the way of kings and I don't think that the stormfather has any idea that Dalinar is a dawnshard. As Dalinar is a radiant I think that it's likely he'll be able to use it properly eventually.
-
QuantumSpren started following How to (and how NOT to) redeem Moash
-
I'm really worried that the teleporting fused can easily sneak on the ship to assassinate people.
-
I hope that at the end of all this he becomes a new shard by mixing the powers of all three shards to become "Unity".
-
There is a WoB Questioner So how did Shallan rescue Kaladin when they fell in the chasm? Brandon Sanderson She did not. It was actually Syl, but he was in the process of breaking the bond, and so she was able to get some Stormlight to him. But that is what really set it really poorly. Like you can imagine, she-- this bond was really a strain for her to use at that point, so it was her. But doing what she did just about destroyed her, which is why you don't hear from her after that. Salt Lake City signing (March 29, 2014)
-
How to (and how NOT to) redeem Moash
QuantumSpren replied to ZenBossanova's topic in Stormlight Archive
I think we'll have to disagree here. The Stormfather was attracted to Dalinar by his search for redemption (as shown by his third oath) not his heinous act in the first place. Killing innocent children just to get revenge on certain people is not honorable in the slightest. Justice is a part of honor not revenge. That is why there is an entire radiant order that is based on Justice. What happened in the rift was revenge not Justice. -
How to (and how NOT to) redeem Moash
QuantumSpren replied to ZenBossanova's topic in Stormlight Archive
I see that, which is why I said that Moash has a warped sense of honor in an earlier post. -
I'll try to do at least a few of these points. 1. Gravity on Roshar is about 0.7 the gravity of the Earth, so that will make a difference. Also the chasms are not that wide seeing as parshendi and shardbearers can jump them. 2. The entire reason that he was truthless was because he "falsely" insisted that the last desolation was coming, and radiants returning are a sign of that, so that put his whole worldview into question. 3. Dalinar was slowing however he was still doing a remarkable job of keeping them honorblade away from himself, so Szeth probably thought that a lashing which just needed a brush of ones fingers instead of a killing blow would be faster and easier. 4. To the crowd it was still somebody defeating impossible odds, everyone likes the underdog winning. 5. The remarkable healing abilities of a radiant are what saved them. Shallan quickly healed from any damage she received with stormlight and kaladin was given stormlight through his degrading bond with syl.
-
How to (and how NOT to) redeem Moash
QuantumSpren replied to ZenBossanova's topic in Stormlight Archive
Are you saying that what Dalinar did with the rift was honorable??? He would be the first to say that it wasn't and he had been looking for forgiveness throughout his entire arc. And Moash killing the king while he is on a path to radiance is not honorable, it is revenge plain and simple. If revenge like Moash did was honorable kaladin would have killed roshone instead of just punching him. -
How to (and how NOT to) redeem Moash
QuantumSpren replied to ZenBossanova's topic in Stormlight Archive
I could forgive him if it was just killing the king, but he has this extremely warped sense of honor, and puts the fused on a pedestal that they really don't deserve just because they aren't human. There are many sympathetic characters among the singers however there are some real monsters among the fused but he insists that "singers are good and humans are bad" while blaming all his failings on being human in almost the reverse of Dalinar accepting his faults and trying to do better. I understand that he is broken in his own way but he refused to even entertain that he could be better. -
How to (and how NOT to) redeem Moash
QuantumSpren replied to ZenBossanova's topic in Stormlight Archive
I personally do not want a redemption arc for "Vyre" as he is the only villian I have ever read that makes me dispise him however, Brandon has both the time (7 >1000 page books) and the skill to make a very satisfying arc if he chooses to. -
According to the Oathbringer Ars Arcanum, gem types are tied but not essential to a radiant soulcasting.