Jump to content

twelfthrootoftwo

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    332

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by twelfthrootoftwo

  1. twelfthrootoftwo
    Well, I think luckat is likely village, after starting that lynch off. Also Frozen mint, and Dalinar and Conquestor to a lesser extent, for jumping on the bandwagon when a bandwagon would effectively determine the lynch. Meta is currently on top of my suspicion list. He tried to divert the lynch, with an argument that seemed more cherry-picked than thought out. I'm also looking at Doctor, for joining the vote on Mark.
  2. twelfthrootoftwo
    If you were a returned, would you decide that cover in case of being checked by a strawman is worth a 50% chance of failing your kill every cycle (even before taking protection into account)? Not entirely accurate - DC was last on 20 minutes after the game started, but he'd have died N1 if he lost his breath then. Therefore DC died to Returned steal N1, and SB died to something else. Ecthelion
  3. twelfthrootoftwo
    Wow... The situation with Mark seems to be one huge IKYK. With five awakened cloths used, it's pretty clear the Returned were planning for this; I'm inclined to think it was an offensive move (which would make Mark a villager) for that reason. One thought I had was to do the lynch in orange, and run it over the night and first 24 hours of the day. Then we total the orange votes and pile on whoever's leading with actual votes. It's more reliable than throwing awakened ropes around, but requires much more coordination. GMs, can one person use more than one of the same item in the same turn?
  4. twelfthrootoftwo
    I had a gut suspicion of Mark after last cycle, and he's had ample time to defend himself so that's where my vote will go for now. I got a PM from him too. Nothing about breath count - he was asking about secret roles, and trying to save Ecthelion. (I mentioned I was suspicious of him in my first reply, and he hasn't responded for two days!) On the other hand, Magestar's responses to suspicion still seem strong, and we now know Bugsy was a villager, so this is another potential avenue if Mark turns out to be village too.
  5. twelfthrootoftwo
    Have we had a clarification about tied votes? Of the two lynch candidates, I think Magestar is marginally more suspicious, mostly for this post (I'm always wary of people addressing suspicion itself, rather than the reasons behind it):
  6. twelfthrootoftwo
    Bard's idea is interesting, but it has problems with potential WGGs - Returned attack one of their own members (or nobody), don't lose any Breath, and use their now-trusted attacked player to get someone else's Breath. Hard to aim, but goes through protection and comes with bonus trust. From an enjoyment perspective, there's also a mayor-like aspect to it; IMO there's a difference between "Lynch this person" and "Get this person to kill themselves because if they don't we lynch them". I found Meta's first post rather jarring compared to his usual playstyle.
  7. twelfthrootoftwo
    Signing up as Kolm. He's an Awakener with a mysterious source of colour that nobody else can see, which he refers to as blue text. However, he hasn't been able to use it as of late, for reasons he doesn't quite understand.
  8. twelfthrootoftwo
    I think I'm regretting signing up for the game. I was on the fence about joining, and there's been far more discussion than I expected. I'm just trying to keep up
  9. twelfthrootoftwo
    Ok, so I guess I should respond to the allegations against me. All I can really say is that there was no basis for the large amounts of votes on any of the lynch candidates so I was ready to jump at any (however small) reason for one persons lynching. Also now can we talk about Night actions? Something of a pattern I noticed. Elodin repeatedly referencing the wolf-brother role feels a bit forced to me - it reads like he's trying to look like it's his role. I'm still suspicious of Elodin; no opinion on Bard. For now, though, where did Winter go?
  10. twelfthrootoftwo
    That's exactly what I was doing. Read between the lines here to find out why. My thoughts on Sart: Elb pointed out that Sart is used to a meta where the 'whether to lynch' discussion is common. With that in mind, him bringing it up to me reads more as a villager trying to kickstart discussion than an eliminator trying to distract. Elodin, for the reason Meta pointed out. It's D1; the village perspective is basically "You're suspicious!" with no faction qualification until something else happens to inform it. You bringing it up suggests it's important to you.
  11. twelfthrootoftwo
    I'm not sure this is a good idea. That means close lynches can be decided by a last-minute mayor vote, even when the player in question has no idea they've been made mayor. Then again, that's true any time we vote one in. Yes she has? I don't think her Kas impression is worthy of two mayor votes, but she's definitely posted.
  12. twelfthrootoftwo
    I wasn't going to join this; I was going to take a break. But... LG6 rerun. Douza and his hammer are in. (Sorry Gamma)
  13. twelfthrootoftwo
    Then Wilson has been lying about her heir. Either she's been suspicious of me and changed her heir without my knowledge, or her heir was Alv so it went to someone random.
  14. twelfthrootoftwo
    What about if this would set up an infinite loop? I'm asking because Wilson might not have attacked Nyali if she knew Nyali was getting a half-shard. ...Now I'm confused. Nyali had a half-shard then (Burnt's), so wouldn't the new half-shard have been destroyed immediately?
  15. twelfthrootoftwo
    Maill, after the half-shard bounced from me, where would it have gone? Because Wilson is my current heir.
  16. twelfthrootoftwo
    Maill has clarified in my PM; that should have been one item. Apologies, Zas. Nyali, clearing Macen requires trusting Zas when he says he tried to take an action., or otherwise confirming he has a knife since Seonid's death (I think that's when they got the second soulcaster?). I used my Soulcaster last cycle to redirect Macen's role action to himself. There's no way to prove that though, unless Macen has a role I'm not aware of.
  17. twelfthrootoftwo
    I spied on you, and discovered you had two items, one being a painrial.
  18. twelfthrootoftwo
    Where'd that painrial come from, Zas?
  19. twelfthrootoftwo
    Alv being GB makes me a little more suspicious of Zas and Wilson. Gonna vote for Kyne though.
  20. twelfthrootoftwo
    Nobody wants to vote? No kill means one of two things: remaining GBs were inactive, or remaining GBs expected to be EBed. Anyone happen to take note of the people who hadn't been on near the end of the night? Guess I'll throw a vote on Alv as the only person I'm not inclined to trust.
  21. twelfthrootoftwo
    I don't think so. I thought it was just the blade that was known. In an effort to get my brain into gear, here are some thoughts on players: So while Alv's logic would be good if Mark's plate was known, I think it would be better to lynch, say, Sheep.
  22. twelfthrootoftwo
    It seems when Maill originally posted the results, only the Grandbow hit was included, which implies Stink landed the killing blow. Which may be why he was the only one revealed. Maill, with multiple attacks hitting the same Full Shardbearer, are they all revealed or just one? If just one, how is it determined (given attacks are simultaneous in the order of actions)? Edit: This is what happens when I leave tabs open
  23. twelfthrootoftwo
    1: With Kas revealed evil, my main reason for trusting Burnt (unbalanced game due to 2-player swing to GBs if her alignment changed) no longer holds. 2: [paranoia]WGG.[/paranoia] GB Burnt requires GB Nyali. 3: Lopen's actions (fishing for info Wilson had) don't make sense if Wilson is evil. Nyali's actions (getting Lopen lynched) don't make sense if she's evil. Really, I don't think either of them are evil. Kynedath
  24. twelfthrootoftwo
    I don't have time to post something more substantial, but since everyone's asking: I successfully protected Nyali last cycle.
  25. twelfthrootoftwo
    So. Lopen, in previous eliminator games, has been an advocate of killing people who suspect his team. I think it's worth checking who the kill targets were suspicious of. Araris - Kynedath and LUNA Joe - Lopen Elodin - Zas (sort of), people who went after DC's thread heiring (so AliasSheep, Nyali, Twei, Kynedath, Elbereth, Kas) STINK - DC, Elb, Alv, people who went after DC's thread heiring (Maybe. I can't tell when STINK is joking.) I suspect Elodin (and Seonid, for that matter) was killed for his soulcaster. STINK may have been targeted for an item, but I don't know what STINK has. Joe was only suspicious of Lopen, who we now know was a GB. Araris suspected LUNA (confirmed Noble) and Kynedath (inactive). My suspicions: Zas and Elbereth - For similar reasons. Neither really want to say much of meaning. Zas in particular seems to want to collect quotes and leave the analysis up to everyone else. Kynedath - Inactive, but regularly online. Burnt - Because paranoia.
×
×
  • Create New...