Leaderboard

All right, I've been blathering on about this for long enough! I've got more from other signings that I am currently working on. Sorry this has taken so long, and enjoy QUESTION: [Josh and Mi’ch] were kind of explaining that your books were all in different worlds and Hoid can jump from world to world? BRANDON: Yes, they’re all in the same universe. And there are some characters who have appeared in multiple books. Hoid, for instance, has appeared in all of them so far. QUESTION: Yeah is he going to have his own book? BRANDON: He will eventually have his own book series. QUESTION: With the Wheel of Time, who’s your favorite character to read about, and then your favorite one to write about? BRANDON: My favorite one to read- during the early parts of the series it was Perrin and during the later parts of the series it was Mat. And my favorite one to write was probably Perrin because- historically, like when I was a young guy reading the books, he was my favorite, he was the one I identified with. QUESTION: I enjoy Way of Kings, it seems like that’s the one where everyone’s coming together. I was reading online about Galladon and Demoux being in it. I enjoyed that. Is that going to happen more often? In that book- that series, yes. There will be more crossover. It’s kinda one of the core stories, along with the things happening on the Mistborn world and things like that. And so, there’s going to be a lot more crossover. Most of it’s still kind of subtle stuff, but if you keep your eyes open there’ll be some real zingers in the next two books. QUESTION: What time period do they all fit in, do they all fit in time- at the same time? BRANDON No, like for instance, Way of Kings and Alloy of Law are pretty close to one another but Elantris is fairly far before them. So far I’ve written them chronologically basically, except I’ve skipped certain stories, like there’s a series called White Sand which is in the middle there somewhere which will actually be a jump back in time when I end up doing it and some things like that. And Dragonsteel is like way at the beginning which I’ll eventually do but I’ve done them chronologically so far. JAREN So, is it next year, 2013 that [stormlight 2] will come out? BRANDON 2013, it’ll be next year. JAREN At the end of the- like the fall? BRANDON Yep, I am a quarter of the way through it, and as long as I turn in an early draft by April they’ll be able to do it by the fall. JAREN So why is Shallan so whiny? No I’m just kidding... BRANDON Shallan is very young and has gone through a lot in her life. JAREN And does she have a Shardblade? BRANDON She does have a Shardblade. QUESTION: Just wanted to ask how you come up with all your different universes? BRANDON You know, it’s hard to say where specifically where they come from. You can point to certain ones and say, Mistborn, Mistborn came from me driving through a fog bank at 80 miles an hour and saying, “Wow that looks cool, can I use that?” And you can point at Warbreaker with me saying, “I’ve done this whole world of ash and I need to do something colorful, let’s build a color based magic system.” Way of Kings is definitely influenced by tidal pools and things like that. And so, each one’s different, it’s just things I see that I think will make interesting stories and settings. QUESTION When are we going to find out about how Elhokar can see like the symbols in the mirror and stuff like that. He can Soulcast then, right? BRANDON You’ll have to see, you’ll have to see... QUESTION: Mark And so like the Windrunners, they’re just one Order of the Knights Radiant, aren’t they? BRANDON Yes they are, in fact they are- every order is a grouping of one of these [points to the large symbols on the Radiant tables] and two of these [points at the smaller symbols], these are the Surges. So these are the ten, sort of forces. And so Windrunning is pressure and gravitation, which are those two. But the Skybreakers are right there [points to gold symbol in the upper middle], with a different combination and each of these different groupings would make one order of the Knights Radiant. And that is the symbol of the Windrunners, right there on the cover. [Points at the swordgylph under the dust jacket]. So, fun little easter-egg type things there. QUESTION: So I was reading the Alloy of Law, and at the end I read through the Ars Arcanum. And I got confused because it’s written in first person, but it refers to Harmony in third person. I thought he was writing it, so who writes that part? BRANDON: That’s a good question for you to be asking, one which people have been curious about, and I have not yet answered who writes all of the Ars Arcanum, but they are in-world, somebody's writing them. If you ever read The Way of Kings, it’s written in first-person too. QUESTION: Are they all written by the same person? BRANDON: Ah, have I answered that yet? JOSH: You should. BRANDON: I should? They are all written by the same person. QUESTION: Because it sounds like they’re written by Hoid, I think. BRANDON: They are all written by the same person. QUESTION: Do you get carpal tunnel? BRANDON: Nope, I don’t. Good question though. Who got carpal tunnel- Dan got carpal tunnel? One of my writer friends got carpal tunnel. QUESTION: So, are you planning on doing anything else with Elantris or Warbreaker universes? BRANDON: I am. I don’t know if you read Emperor’s Soul but it’s in the Elantris universe. It’s set on a different continent, so you have to keep your eyes open to see the connections but the magic systems are working on the same fundamental formula. You will enjoy that one if you liked Elantris and Warbreaker I will get back to eventually. QUESTION: Oh, my question was does Perrin lose a body part in the book, since Mat has lost one, Rand has lost one, does Perrin lose one next? BRANDON: Perrin’s body part was the knee, where he got shot through the leg with the arrow. Because the mythological symbolism is with Mat- it’s the Odin mythology, and Odin lost an eye. Perrin is actually the blacksmith mythology, which if you’ve read in Hephaestus and Perun and of the various blacksmiths, they usually have a bad leg. I wasn’t going to chop off his leg. I had that wound, and he kind of feels a phantom wound, if you’ll read in the last book there are several times where his leg aches even though he was healed. That’s the symbolism there. QUESTION: So, did you just decide to [inaudible] or was that..? BRANDON: No, Robert Jordan had done that, that was him. QUESTION: I wasn’t sure if I was just coming up with a fantasy or not. BRANDON: Though I knew he had to be wounded in the leg, I didn’t know how or how badly so I kind of came up with how it happened. BRANDON’S DAD: Brandon started reading Robert Jordan when he was nine and ten, and he used to get under the covers with a candle. And his mother liked to stay up, he’s a night owl, so his mother would stay up til one or two in the morning. And so then he’d blow the candle out before she’d come up. So what I did was I got him a flashlight so he could read better, but I got him a great big one like this. [guestures] So she’d holler up and say, “Are you still up there Brandon,” and he’d say, “No!”. So, when he was little he was reading these books, Robert Jordan’s books, he read every single one. I’d take him down and he’d play pinball or go over and write books. And then when he got into junior high it was cards, Dungeons and Dragons, that kind of stuff. So that’s a true story you can put that on your website. Almost burned the house down a couple of times. QUESTION: If you make a Feruchemical storage and you burn it, can you put the excess back into a Feruchemical storage? BRANDON: Yes. QUESTION: Brandon, have we seen a point of view chapter from the character who writes the Ars Arcanum? BRANDON: I’m not gonna tell you that. That would be way too much giving away. QUESTION: Is the character who writes the Ars Arcanum from Sel originally? BRANDON: I’m not gonna tell you anything about the character who writes the Ars Arcanum. QUESTION: Is the city that the Parshendi are in Urithiru? (pronounced:You-rith-ir-oo) BRANDON: In the Way of Kings, Jasnah tells Shallan that Urithiru is not on the Shattered Plains. So either Jasnah is incorrect or that is not Urithiru. QUESTION: In other words, you’re not going to tell me? BRANDON: I’m just clarifying for you so that you have all the information you need in order to make judgements and ask questions. QUESTION: Is it possible to build a city that only exists in Shadesmar? BRANDON: Yes. QUESTION: Do people inhabit Shadesmar, like normal people? BRANDON: Define normal. QUESTION: Let’s rephrase that, describe the people that inhabit Shadesmar. BRANDON: Well, you have seen people who inhabit Shadesmar. QUESTION: The next question I have is does Odium have to recover after Shattering a Shard? BRANDON: It is a difficult process that is very taxing. QUESTION: What is the technology level of the singular society that existed when Adonalsium Shattered? BRANDON: What was the technology level of the society that existed when Adonalsium Shattered? It was less than our own. QUESTION: Are you going to give us anything more specific than that? BRANDON: Less than our own BRANDON: Adonalsium is not Shattered in Dragonsteel. QUESTION: Do you have any more Legion? Is there anywhere to find it or is a limited print run? BRANDON: Ah, Legion had a limited print run, but we are in discussions that- enough people are asking that that I think we’re going to do a paperback that’ll come out. So, eventually we should be releasing a little paperback of that that you can get. At the very least you should be able to get it on my website eventually. This is the first time I’d done something that small and we didn’t know about the limited edition and things so we just wanted to do- we were very cautious about it and it sold out very quickly. So hopefully we’ll be able to do some more. QUESTION: Can Cadsuane’s Aes Sedai, Merise, Corele, and Beldeine, use the bond to compel their Asha’man? BRANDON: Wow. Oh boy. I’m going to have such trouble with her questions. I have trouble with her questions when I’m steeped in the Wheel of Time lore and working on the notes every day, and now that I haven’t even looked at them in like ten months... QUESTION: Tell her to ask Maria? BRANDON: But that’s one I should know, is the thing. It’s not a hard question. It’s just one where I’m... I don’t think they can. But, you should really ask Maria. But I don’t think they can. I should know that one, you can tell her I should know that one, but I don’t think they can. I knew it at one point. QUESTION: Will we find out what happened to Taren Ferry in A Memory of Light? BRANDON: Umm, I’ll tell people if they can’t infer it, eventually what happened. QUESTION: Have Elayne’s axe and red-hot iron been fulfilled? BRANDON: Axe and red-hot iron been fulfilled? You can ask Maria but I believe they have. QUESTION: Approximately how old are the scabbard and hilt of Rand’s new sword? BRANDON: [Laughter] RAFO JOSH: Does Nicola’s Foretelling represent a single moment in time? BRANDON: Which one is she talking about? JOSH: Three on the boat, and he who is dead yet lives. The great battle done, but the world not done with battle. The land divided by the return, and the guardians balance the servants. The future teeters on the edge of a blade BRANDON: MAFO. I’m gonna MAFO that one. I think I know that one, but I don’t think I want to touch it. MI’CH: Was the Reod natural? BRANDON: The Reod natural? [Laughs] MI’CH Here’s the thing, you’ve answered this question for us already, we just need it on audio. JOSH: It wasn’t the Reod that was the question it was was the earthquake natural? MI’CH: No, Eric’s asking if the Reod was natural. JOSH: To heck with Eric, we don’t care about him. MI’CH You’ve told us that the earthquake was not caused by natural events. BRANDON: Yeah, it’s a complicated question because the earthquake was not caused by natural but the Reod was a natural effect of the earthquake, then... does that make sense? So the Reod is natural, a natural result of... does that make sense? That’s why it was a tricky question. MI’CH: But the earthquake was not natural. BRANDON: No, it was not. AARON: So the Reod is a natural reaction to an unnatural occurrence. BRANDON: Yes. JOSH: And wasn’t it because there was like magical strain on the land? BRANDON: That is certainly part of what was going on. QUESTION:: People will be making your books into movies soon, right? BRANDON: I’m hoping, we’re trying. QUESTION: Which one first? BRANDON: Mistborn, we’re working very hard to try and get it made. I can’t promise but we’re trying. QUESTION: Who do you want to be like Vin and Elend? BRANDON: I don’t really cast people in my head. And so I would rather let the director decide that and the casting director and things. It’s not one of my things, is to cast people. For a while, I really- I was kind of hopeful for Ellen Page, but I don’t think that’s viable now, I think that she’s too old now. QUESTION: When is the timeline for the sequel to Alloy of Law? BRANDON: Sequel for Alloy of Law? Probably not next year but the year after. I’m pretty dominated by finishing the second Stormlight book right now. So once I do that, then things will open up a little bit more for what I might do. I do actually have half a sequel for Alloy of Law written but I don’t have time to finish it right now. BRANDON: So what’s going on here is, for Stormlight 2 I needed a lullaby in-world. And poetry is not my forte. However, my father-in-law is a semi-professional singer/songwriter. He’s released a couple of albums, they’re just local, he does stuff like that. So, I asked him to compose a lullaby that I just left blanks in the story from. And he actually turned it in just like a couple of days ago. And it’s quite good and it fits in. So, what I’ve been doing lately is writing on Stormlight 2. And Stormlight 2, if you’re unaware with what’s going on in the Stormlight series, I conceived the series as ten volumes, two five book arcs, with each volume focusing on a character by giving them a flashback sequence. So if you’ve read the first one, Kaladin, one of the main characters, there’s a sequence of flashbacks that kind of inform how he came to be where he is at the start of the book. And I intended that for each of the ten primary characters because I kind of began them all in the middle of their stories, which is what happens when you’re writing a book. The beginning of a story is not the beginning of a book. It’s impossible to tell the beginning of a story because there’s always something more that could come before. So you start with people who have passions, who have lives, who have things going on and then I wanted to use these sequences to bring you back up to where they were when they started. This was a method I thought I would use in order to help divide each book and help me envision each book as a stand-alone volume in the series. Because one of the challenges of writing a big series like this is you don’t want them all to blend together. You want them each to feel distinct, to have their own climaxes and their own story because when they start to blend together it can be detrimental to the series in the long run. So in my original outline, I spent a lot of time figuring out what everyone’s story was going to be but I didn’t actually have to do them in a certain order because they all are flashbacks I didn’t have to have the flashbacks in certain parts. And so I wasn’t sure whether I was going to do Dalinar or Shallan for the second book, I always knew I was going to do Kaladin for the first book. And I ended up deciding on Shallan, in part because I want to get into her story because of things that are happening in the plot but also because I wanted Dalinar’s sequence to come later. Now, I’m not promising that characters all survive that long. It’s entirely possible, just so you know, that I would kill someone off and still show their flashback sequence. Because the flashbacks aren’t them having a flashback, the flashbacks are- it’s not them sitting there and remembering that, it is simply a non-linear way of telling their story. So just so you know, that doesn’t necessarily mean that Dalinar survives til book five. What I’m going to do, is I’m going to do the first of the Shallan flashbacks for Stormlight 2. This is stuff that I’ve been writing fairly recently and I haven’t done any drafts of this. So it’s gonna be a little rough, this might change, in fact it will change between now and when it gets published but you get to have a look at it. For those who didn’t hear, there’s a lullaby in this that my father-in-law wrote. I asked him, I commissioned him actually, just like you commissioned an artist to do things like Shallan’s sketchbook, I commissioned a song to go in here as part of the lullaby. So I’m going to be referring to that because I only got this in last week. So you’re hearing fresh stuff, that might change as well. So this is Shallan, I have named it “Chapter Shallan Flashback One: Red Carpet, Once White.” The world ended and Shallan was to blame. "Pretend it never happened," her father whispered, he wiped something wet from her cheek, his thumb came back red. "I'll protect you." Was the room shaking? No, that was her, trembling. She looked up at her father, moving with a sudden jerk. She couldn't blink, her eyes were frozen open. "Sleep now, dear one, Crimson sky will fly before you." A lullaby, father whispered it through his tears. Behind him, in the room, dark corpses lay stretched out on the floor. Red carpet, once white. "Though rock and dread may be your bed, You will sleep my loved one dear" Father gathered her into his arms. And she felt her skin squirming. No... no... This affection wasn't right. A monster should not be held in love, a monster who killed, who murdered. No... But she could not move. "Now comes the storm, But you'll be warm. The wind may shake your dreams." Father stepped over the body of a woman in white. Little blood there. It was the other men doing most of the bleeding. Mother lay face down so Shallan couldn't see the eyes, the horrible eyes. Almost, Shallan could imagine that the lullaby was the end to a nightmare. That it was night, and that she had awakened screaming. That her father was singing her to sleep. As he'd done when she was a child. "The crystals fine, will glow sublime. So sleep my loved one dear." They passed father's safe on the wall. It glowed brightly, light streaming from the cracks around the closed front. A monster was inside. "And like a song, it won't be long. You'll sleep, my loved one dear." Father left the bedroom and closed the door on the corpses. So that’s flashback one. You will find out, those who have read the first book know that there are things going on in Shallan’s past, she mentions one of them near the end of the book, if you’ll remember, and there is supposition about something with Shallan mentioning several times the phrase, “ten heartbeats” which is a somewhat important measure in this world. QUESTION: If you slash somebody with a Shardblade, kill them, and then cut them again, will the Shardblade make them bleed? BRANDON: Yes. Just like a chasmfiend once it dies, they are chopping it apart with Shardblades.

It's a very difficult question to answer, and it really isn't a good benchmark. He wrote a book called "The Way of Kings" (he now refers to it as Way of Kings Prime) before Elantris was published which was much shorter than it is now (it was about 306K words vs over 380K). He then spent the next eight years doing worldbuilding and editing. The first reference to a rewrite I can find on his blog is in May of 09. He then finished his rewrite two months later, so I'm not sure if it really only took him that long. He's good, but rewriting that much in two months with Sundays off is 7300 words per day. Also, with the rewrite, there was a major change to the plot regarding a choice Kaladin made before the story began, so his plot was VERY different in PRIME. Plus what Flash said... It's a really tough question. If Peter gets on, he'll have a better answer. http://brandonsanderson.com/blog/784/Another-Long-Winded-Explanation-of-Various-Things http://brandonsanderson.com/blog/803/DONE?m=1&y=2009&d=4

Do we know that Honor created humans? They moved in from the TH, and it's not entirely implausible that Cultivation made them first and Honor just joined the fun. I guess what I'm getting at is this: what if Honor hadn't expended very much of himself on humans/Odium spent too much of himself on the Shards, and as a result the two were actually evenly matched? Odium couldn't just bruteforce his way through Honor becauce it would kill him, or at least leave him easy pickings for Cultivation. (It's also possible that, though they were both weak from making humans, together they could match Odium. Same thing though, in the end.) So they did the Ruin/Preservation thing, Honor tries to make people honorable, Odium blocks him. Odium tries to make people hateful, Honor blocks him. They go on like this until the sheer pointlessness sets in. So the two/three of them set up a roundabout way of getting at one another. They create the Oathpact, probably with some Shardic magic we don't really understand. How it worked is anybody's guess. Maybe they fought only with creations, maybe they did something else. Who can say? The important thing seems to be that they left a lot of their battle up to humans, kind of Diablo style I guess. This is where I get back on topic, for those who were fingering the downrate button. Maybe their shardic prescence had already given people powers ages ago during their push and shove match. In any case, now that they've figured out how stupid directly fighting is, they probably went down and did what they could to perfect the magic systems they had created. Honor got surgebinding, likely an improved and more honor-powered version of whatever people originally being given by him. Then we have Voidbinding. The name sounds pretty obvious, all things considered, and normally we'd just slap this onto Odium and get to work on Cultivation. But we know enough about the natures of Shards like Ruin and Odium to not just take things by their names. The name doesn't match up with what we know. Voidbinding is, as far as we've been told, a way to see the future. The mechanics we've seen for doing so pretty much boil down to people who die. So, for the sake of the theory, we'll say Voidbinding is in some way related to that, like the OP says, and move on. Honor has told us that Cultivation is pretty good at seeing the future, which is a little suspicious since Voidbinding is supposed to be Odium's thing. We also have the problem of Voidbringers supposedly holding stormlight perfectly. If they can hold stormlight, that means surgebidning. Do they have two magic systems? If so, why didn't Surgebinding get lumped in with Voidbinding over time? Nobody speaks evilly of people changing gravity and sending people into the atmosphere. With what we've seen of Shards, it's not too far of a stretch to say that Odium has changed theology to prevent anybody from stopping him via precognicion, and that either Voidbringers have a system we haven't heard of yet or that they have some form of Hemalurgy that lets them use the other powers alongside their own. Okay, that was a big rambling textwall that may or not have made any sense. Sorry :/

I dropped down, straight towards the water. At the last moment, Alfie bolted from my shoulder, I was not sure where. I slowed down just enough to make impact bearable, and splashed into the canal, pack and all. It wasn't too deep here, and I almost touched bottom before Pulling myself towards the shore and surface. The chill of the water cleared my thoughts, and the water itself cleans my body well, removing most of the smell that started to bother me. My steel and iron run out as I I propel myself on the shore, and I land somewhat less than gracefully. Water streams from my clothing. I scan the rooftops in the direction of the late Harmony's base. Nobody seems to have pursued us. That was well. Of course, I couldn't see as well as Alfie did, with his tin. I was getting tired. My pewter was also severely drained during the flight. On the other hand, we landed not too far from my house, and I knew of nice, discrete entry to the underground lab, where we could rest, or at least replenish our resources. Shrugging off as much water as I could, I set up in that direction, hoping that Alfie would follow.

They could just have a localized effect where their words are translated for them. Taln could be speaking Dawnchant, and it's being translated to the guards as Alethi, much like Dalinar in his visions is speaking Alethi to himself, but is actually speaking Dawnchant to Navani and company.

This seems unwieldy when you are one of ten people chosen to lead basically a whole world to war. "For battle directions in Alethi, please press one. For Horneater, please press two. For Makabi, please press three. If you do not hear your language of choice, please charge headfirst at the enemy. Thank you, and have a nice Desolation"

These are from a specific PoV. From my PoV, I don't have an accent. Australians might think.otherwise.

First...sorry for the confusion. I thought you were responding to the fact that Spren were not attracted to an attribute, in addition to saying that jasnah is not bonded to a truthspren. I didn't see Jasnah as being confused by the truthspren, just shocked that Shallon could see them. Telling the truth is not honesty, as you stated. You can be honest, and still express untruth mistakenly. You can have the truth, and choose not to be honest. Honesty is a characteristic of nobility (coming from the same root as honor), or a need to 'tell it like it is'. So in the phrase 'tell it like it is' Honesty would be the 'tell it' and truth would be the 'is'. Honesty will, at least once, produce truth, but truth does not necessarily ever need to produce honesty. I am not going to go to the mats on what kind of spren she is bonded to, if any. However, Jasnah's whole life is dedicated to finding out the truth; she is a veristatalian. I believe from the latin Veritas meaning: truth. She may not be honest all the time, but she is VERY interested in, and in posession of much, Truth. So here come the truthspren )

This is feasible. One thing to keep in mind is that mistwraiths are people who have a blockage between the physical and the cognitive realm, messing with their ability to think. Think of them as mentally-stunted people. There's enough there to train, but then you have to dig into the ethics of it... Hemalurgy can give allomantic powers to a kandra. The process to do so is not known to anyone but Harmony.