Leaderboard

Reviving/Necro-ing this post from the dead because I now have a direct WoB about this for both Steel and Iron lines. Yes, both can be used to identify specific metals, and it is not limited to only savants. This seems to be something any misting or mistborn could do with enough practice.

Day 2: Unquenchable Fire Quintus sprinted across the beach. First of the Sun was a dangerous place, and an experienced worldhopper - even one who had once been trained by Hoid himself! (though that was long ago, in a life so far gone that it seemed more a dream) - could find themselves in a great deal of trouble if they allowed themselves to become complacent. As he had. The great sea creature heaved itself up onto the searing hot sand, vast maw snapping at its prey. Quintus rolled into the jungle, breathing heavily. The leviathan slid back into the deeps, leaving a track in the sand. He breathed a sigh of relief, almost calming down. That had been careless of him. He would have to pay more attention to such things in the future. The news of his old master’s return had apparently disturbed him more than he knew. He was still uncertain of how to respond to it. His instincts almost saved him. Without even knowing why, Quintus rolled to his side. A bolt of fire, as hot as the inside of a star, streaked past him, igniting a twenty foot section of the jungle where it struck. Pulling out of his roll, he frantically searched for his attacker. He caught a brief glimpse of a shadowed figure, eyes alight with hatred more powerful than anything he had ever known. Then the second bolt of fire struck his chest, and he saw no more. Quintus (Jondesu) was killed! His role and alignment will be revealed when he passes to the Spiritual Realm! Jack Tormander (A Joe in the Bush) has been Returned! Day 2 has begun. As noted in the signup thread, it will be extended for 24 hours, and will end at 2:00 PM, December 26th (Mountain Time) The vote has been tallied, and the players overwhelmingly voted for 24 hour nights. All future nights in this game will remain at 24 hours unless specifically extended. Player List: 1. Assassin in Burgundy - First of the Game 2. Master Elodin - Second of the Signups 3. Jondesu - Quintus 4. AliasSheep - Kelen Taldar 5. Darkness Ascendant - Kaldain Selblessed 6. A Joe in the Bush - Jack Tormander Returned 7. Doc12 - Silence 8. Kynedath - Desten Kyde 9. TheMightyLopen - Kaloo 10. Straw - Malum Farcimen 11. Young Bard - Serol 12. Magestar - Magestar 13. Alvron - Lorna 14. Dalinar Kholin - Sanya 15. Harambe - PUNisher 16. I_am_a_Stick - Stic 17. RubiksCube - cubefright archive 18. DroughtBringer - Ralar 19. Araris Valerian - Aralis 20. Arinian - Arinian 21. Zephrer - Tardeick 22. Conquestor - Farallen Oniz 23. Sart - Sam Trudite 24. Aonar Faileas - Nilan Izenry 25. Elenion - emissary of Mandos 26. Kasimir - Tenth of the Dusk

As the last surviving representative of House Urbain (*cough* the House of Paranoia *cough*), I'd like to erase the possibility of Elodin-Joe collusion by asking Elodin to do a vote-swap on the next day. Good way to forestall doubters too, I think, since Elodin's investment should vanish whether he does or doesn't do anything (leaving aside the "Who is Cultivation?" question.) [Actually, GMs, could I confirm if Cultivation's investment also has a time limit or whether it doesn't? This is not clear to me from the rules text. @Seonid, @Elbereth] This, of course, is me assuming no one starts as an Elantrian, but I find this a tad likely, since some minor roles are bestowed by Endowment. (Technically, this doesn't rule out the possibility he could be Hoid, or Endowment, but then, at least it sets up one plausible case for us. I see the latter case as being less likely.) This would also prevent an Awakener from having to out themselves. (I think.) Other than that, I really don't see what would be the point of resurrecting Joe at this point in time. First, I generally like more robust confirmation of a player's allegiances before we do something like Return them. I'm not seeing this here - just chains of assumptions that have only been weakly tested. (One method of testing has been suggested above.) Even if Joe is Cultivation, returning him to life won't give him back his Shard, will it? It'll just make him a big, honking target screaming, "HEY, I'M A PRETTY MUCH CONFIRMED VILLAGER, COME CONVERT ME!" to practically everyone, including Hoid, Odium, and Autonomy. Conversely, if you think Hoid, Odium and Autonomy won't find a returned Joe attractive, the problem is that the possibility still exists, since it essentially becomes about trying to outguess everyone who can convert people in this game. In a conversion game, scans and confirmation are a commodity, always offered in degrees, never in absolutes. All the more so for one like this. So I don't really see the point in that reasoning. (Of course, if you think Joe is a good player and you want him alive because of that, then that's a different story.) Now, it's not to say we can't win with Odium and Autonomy, but the worrying question is whether Odium and Autonomy see their play as being with us. If it doesn't, then we're still in an awkward position anyway - and it's just worsened once you throw Team Hoid into the mix. P.S. Let's keep an eye on those who voted. Squabbling over Day 1 lynches aside, I have a feeling at least some of those who voted were people who really wanted to receive an extra action. Tenth of the Dusk slipped away. He was not appalled or shocked: not entirely. You did not live years on Patji without learning there were questions which need not be asked, without an appreciation for swift killing efficiency. He had his eye on another, though. He knew a fellow hunter when he saw one. For now, he kept Kaikoa close. He did not want to lose hold of him, in this place. He had come to the feast only because he was asked to. This place - this city - it was not his. He did not think he knew how to feel comfortable, even now, within the dense buildings of a city, rather than the lush, killing jungles of the Pantheon islands. They did not frighten him, those hulking men in gleaming metal shells. He had known greater terrors than those. Still, Tenth was not reckless. And like most of the guests at this feast, he was hardly unarmed. The other guests were discussing the killing in soft, frightened whispers. Some of them were leaving, like himself. Probably to the worlds from which they had come. Tenth did not understand this. Why order everyone to remain in Silverlight, only to ask them to return to their tasks - some of which lay elsewhere? It made no sense. Kaikoa nibbled lightly on his ear. "Hush," Tenth said, pre-emptorily, although Kaikoa had not chirped. He made up his mind. He would go: back to his world, back to his safecamp (he could not shed the term so easily, even now), and then he would make his decisions there. Khriss had offered a hunt. Tenth did not intend to go back on his word. But he did not like this situation, either. It was a nest of deathants, and if he'd known... He left.

Basically cat food But here are some tips: 1. When buying cat food, always check how many %of it is meat. The best known brands like Whiskas have terrible ingridients. 4% meat and the rest are grains and other non-meat ingredients. Good cat food starts from 50% meat. 2. You can feed him raw chicken or beef, just wash it and chop it, but make sure not to leave any bones. Especially in chicken. If they break and get swallowed they can puncture the intestine which would result in painful death or very costly surgery. 3. Dry cat food is OK, but don't make it his main source of food. Cats absorb most of water they need with the meat they should eat, so it's healthier for them to eat "wet" food. 4. If you decide to base his diet on raw meat, make sure to supplement him with vitamins and minerals. They are added to canned cat food, but are not present in chicken breasts etc. Some general tips: 1. If you want to keep him/her be warned that he might have fleas. They are usuall easy to get rid of when you have only one animal, but some find them gross and are terrified. 2. This cat lived on the streets so for 99% if has internal parasites. They too should be easily curable. You can do it in two ways. First one, more costly, is to gather some of its feces and have them tested in the lab to find out what there is to kill and then buy a medicine best suited for this kind of parasite. The second option is to just buy a medicine that has the widest range of effect. I personally usually go with the second option as a start, because it's cheaper and faster. Then only if I see any symptoms that parasites might still be there I go to the lab. 3. If you want to keep the cat in your house, provide it with at least 2 litter boxes, that will reduce the chances of him doing his business somewhere you don't want I could keep going and going with this,but I guess that's all for the start if you have any questions feel free to PM me

And that is the story of the Seon that got so depressed that it stopped glowing and turned grey and opaque such that you couldn't see its aon anymore. It was named Eey. And that's how Eeyore got his name.

The world now has an ebola vaccine. Score another one for Science!

...So, you're gonna start flying Secessionist? (You dodged one bad joke, not two. I'm sorry.) But... I admit, I'm the type of person who would probably get over specific with regulations and technicalities. But yeah, at least try being nice and apologetic and sorry while you're enforcing asinine rules. It... doesn't make much of a difference, but still. It's nice to be nice, I guess?

My name is Riah, and I'm from London in the United Kingdom. It's a pleasure to meet you all! Really looking forward to posting here and getting to know everyone

Friends, gather around. I have uncovered the greatest secret of all time. Perhaps this has been revealed before and, if it has, bless the Sharder who first found it. If it has not been revealed before, or if this post can reach just one more person and help them understand the depth to which Brandon has prepared the Cosmere for our enjoyment, then I think this post is not in vain. I quote from Elantris, page 466 and 467 of the Kindle version: This is where "Raoden" fixed Elantris by adding the chasm line to the city. Or, rather, this is where THE STICK fixed Elantris! Compare this to the following passage from Words of Radiance page 143 and 144 of the Kindle edition: Is it not suspicious that one of the beads that "surged" up to Shallan would happen to be a... nay, THE stick? It is, to me, quite obvious that the stick Raoden used to add the chasm line to Elantris is the exact same stick Shallan communicated with after the santhid rescued her. Note how the stick Shallan is speaking to "sound satisfied"... perhaps this stick was feeling so satisfied because it knew that it had been, literally and figuratively, instrumental in saving Elantris from the Dakhor monks! Perhaps this particular stick is now deeply embroiled in the fight against Odium in the Roshar system and, therefore, simply could not turn to fire for Shallan because the stick still had so much work to do. Perhaps Brandon Sanderson has given us a massive clue as to the fate of the Cosmere and we have been distracted by some doofus named Hoid (or whatever) and missed this obvious clue given in the very first published work! Also, lest we forget, there was an entire chapter of missing information about the stick that Sanderson gave us - I will quote the relevant portions of the chapter below! I propose a re-read of every Cosmere work with a distinct emphasis on finding out what the stick has been up to! I would wager that we can find the stick in each published work, quietly providing assistance to the characters of the book and not at all upset that Hoid (or whomever) has been soaking up all the glory! Truly, the stick is the worldhopper we need to focus on if we plan on teasing out more details on the Cosmere. edit: weird strike-through error corrected

Hi guys, I'm glad I found this place with all you fellow Sanderfans. It is awesome here. I hope you guys like weird theories, (sometimes) obscure music references, strange attempts at humor, odd questions, and totally random Cosmere/Reckoners/Alcatraz/Other Sanderson Novels stuff, because this is probably 99% of what i'm going to be posting! Enjoy!

Same man. I was kind of hoping i wouldn't get returned, because I'm tired of being the center of discussion, and people are still suspicious of me. First off, i'm not voting for Lopen like i did last time. that vote was stupid, and i was angry at him for voting for me on day 1, and i overreacted. Even if people didn't see it, i was pissed by the day 1 vote. Which is also why i decided to not save myself. I could have by tieing the vote, as many of you have already said, but i'm getting better at recognizing unhealthy signs of anger, so i decided to let myself die and give my self time to cool down. About halfway through the night i realized i needed to not be returned, since as long as I'm still alive, Everyone is going to think that Elodin and I are on the same team. (In retrospect, i should have invested in someone like Sheep.) Oh yeah, Elodin doesn't have Cultivation. To the current wielder of Cultivation. My Meta-narrative backers would very much like you to get rid of it. Nothing else on that. Anyway, conversions. I'm going to use my returned power and kill myself at the end of night 3. That is a solemn oath. I will only not kill myself at the end of Night 3 if Over half of the surviving players tell me not to, or I have been converted. This is to prevent me being converted, because now if i don't kill myself at the end of night 3, I'm sure to be lynched by the village, and therefore a conversion is wasted. (#Kira-not-Kira). I wish I had more time to keep talking and responding, but I have to head out in about 5 minutes, so this is all you're going to get for the next 6 hours.

Say what you will about Spokane, but it is beautiful this time of year. It's snowing gently as I type this, and it's already covered the roof and the yard and the nearby pine trees. Bruce bounds through it like a bunny rabbit—between bouts of chasing Mollie through the house, that is. I'm sitting on a bed in the guest room, with Bruno curled up next to me. The parents were happy to see me, so it seems like this will be a more pleasant visit. I'm super tired, but can't sleep, so I'm here typing instead.

Anyone else suddenly want to play Plants vs Zombies: Cosmere Edition?

When you and all of your sanderfriends got together about once a month to eat chouta, carry a homemade bridge around BYU campus, sing Sanderson-inspired song and recite the first KR oath, and talk Sanderson. When each of you has a cosmere - mostly bridge four - name (I was Nazh). The joys of living in Utah, that there are some 15 of us. Sadly, the two group leaders have now left for their LDS missions, and the group fell apart.

I guess it's that magical time of year again when we all gather together around the Random Stuff thread and share the gift of pet pictures. Here's fifteen photos of my assorted animals. Merry Christmas.

A Hearthwarming Tail is Best Christmas Special. Hope ya'all enjoy whatever you have planned for the season, and happy New Year!

I'm 5"1, have brown hair halfway down my back with caramel/light brown highlights, tan skin (I like to pretend i'm alethi ) with dark brown eyes. My avatar is a picture of me from back when I dyed my hair a lighter shade of brown

Found in Warbreaker

Harambe is a new player and some of the rules can be confusing so I think he just got some of the terms mixed up. Or he could be playing the newbie card but I like to give people the benefit of the doubt. Unless they happen to be Kas.

Just landed in Spokane! Bruce was very well behaved during both flights, which was awesome. More importantly, my family said they'll have water for me. I'm running on a cup of tea and two 20 ounce bottles.

I think we're mostly in agreement then, but if you will allow me to clarify the point on Haemalurgy. In order to steal anything with Haemalurgy you need 3 things: the correct intent, the correct bind point, and the correct metal. If you were to try and find a new combination therefore, you would need to test every bind point with every metal (though depending on how much you know of the system, you could narrow the metal down by the category of the attribute that you're trying to steal). We know that there's between 200 and 300 bind points in the human body, so if we assume 256 to keep to the base 2 nature of the metallic arts, that means that you'd need a maxiumum of 256*16 = 4096 guinea pigs. Whereas if you had atium, you would effectively eliminate one of the variables. You would still need to test for the correct metal afterwards, but it reduces the maximum to 256+16 = 272 guinea pigs, a far more manageable number. [This doesn't look anywhere near evil enough, why don't we have an evil grin option?]

Point of resurrecting Joe for me it's activity in this game, he was one of the most active players on the first day. I'm just don't want this game to fall in inactivity same as LG28. Also there can be possibility that Joe was Odium and Elodin now his champion (I know there really small possibility but let’s just guess it). And I don't think that it's really big threat for us if he gonna be converted by Odium or Autonomy. And if he gonna be converted by Hoid it's even good for us cause 17th Shard have limited conversion (If I remember it right). That with what I absolutely agree.

Ha! I placed my order right before you with #1037. I wasted 3-4 minutes trying to get my question down to 90 characters. Here it is in all of it's glory:

1. Unsubstantiated assertion. Try again. 2. Unsubstantiated assertion + wishful thinking. Try again. 3. Fair point, in which case Endowment has far better things to be doing. See: arguments unaddressed except by unsubstantiated, sweeping assertions.

So I've been reading everyone's replies and all the feedback has been really appreciated, I'm gonna keep adding images to the main post as I work so stay tuned! I see there's been a lot of talk about spike counts. I think I'm going to go with a balance between canon and aesthetically pleasing. The default ten spikes seem a bit low for me so I'll probably add some. I will at least add one through the heart, and maybe more in the back even though none are mentioned (it looks more like a spine that way). I'm hesitant to add too many to the rib cage for fear of things getting crowded, but I'll withhold judgement until I test that. Thanks again everybody!

@Elbereth Feel free to edit this in when you get back PSA on Shardic Abilities: A Shard has two unique actions they may take - they may invest (which may only be done during the Day Turn) and they may use a unique Shardic action (which may only be done during the Night Turn). If a Shard chooses not to invest in another player, they may essentially "self-invest" during the Day Turn (using one of their actions like normal). This lets them use their investment ability instead of their Shardic ability, as if they had been invested by the Shard they hold. Essentially, it costs 2 actions for a Shard's investment ability to be used (unless it is a passive investment) - if they invest in another, it takes one of their for the investment and one of their investee's to use the ability. If they invest in themselves, it takes 2 of their own actions (unless it is a passive ability).

Shallan, hands down. There's a reason my wife and I decided to give our daughter the middle name "Shallan" <.< We call her baby monitor "Pattern." We're such dorks. (So far, she's living up to the name - her eyes are currently bright blue, she was smiling before 1 month, she was laughing at 2 months, she started signing at 4 months (only the word "diaper," but still), and now she's scooting (and very close to true crawling) at 6 months. We'll see what happens when she gets old enough for crayons! #proudmom)

This is the most hilarious article I've ever read on a wiki, ever. Especially out of context. http://coppermind.net/wiki/Stick

Sorry I'm late, but welcome to the Shard! Have an upvote! I'm Shqueeves, and, since it seems to be a thing on this thread, I'm a highschooler from Utah.

Why not have free snacks on the ski lift?

Oh yea it adds quite a bit of background and it's just plain fun to watch. I'd watch it asap. I watched it before I even hit play on game as it's a prequel

When you decide that if you ever own a ski resort, you'll name a ski-lift Wyndle.

A woman is on trial for beating her husband to death with his guitar collection. Judge asks, "First offender?" She replies, "No, first a Gibson, then a Fender."

Wow, never would have thought it, but this sounds great! I support Kal and Shallan but I certainly wouldn't mind seeing this! As for Jasnah/Kaladin, I can't help but feel that Jasnah, in all her wisdom and poise, would find him to be slightly insufferable and naive. As much as we love Kal, he's still going to be growing and learning from his experiences, he's only 20 after all. She'll probably see him the way she sees Adolin.

@Bugsy6912 I haven't read very many, but my family has an audible account, and I've listened to most of them (I'm being extra careful not to misspell any names) I think my favorite was either one of the boks from the original Mistborn Trilogy, Sixth of Dusk, or Words of Radiance (I'm bad at deciding). My favorite non-Cosmere Sanderson novel is one of the Reckoners books (again, it's hard to decide). @Zathoth I liked the Book of Souls. Was better than Virtual XI (though I will admit I thought some of the songs from Virtual XI were pretty good), but not as good as some of their early works (Killers, Number of the Beast, Powerslave, etc.,) The Great Unknown is my favorite song from the album (though If Eternity Should Fail and Speed of Light were also awesome). I think you got me about right, though I like most kinds of metal and rock (I even liked Judas Priest's album Jugulator, though I thought it sounded ABSOLUTELY nothing like classic Judas Priest). As for the kind of twinborn I am I'd probably be a Chromium Feruchemist and a Benadalloy Allomancer (though being a thug or a tineye would also be pretty cool).

When you see a 'Standard Archive Box' and take a moment to think of Stormlight.

Obvious photoshop is obvious. If that's a cat, where are it's poisonous back quills?

Welcome to the forums, and what a great question to start out with! The answer gets pretty deep into realmatics, so buckle up, 'cause this is gonna get messy. Metals themselves don't produce Investiture; they are keys to Investiture, which comes from a Shard. We do know that metals from another world are useable for Allomancy; if you're watching very carefully, you just might see it in Stormlight. Metal is an additional cost, like water is in White Sand or color is Warbreaker. The magic doesn't come from water (probably), it doesn't come from color. The magic is all drawn from the Shard behind that magic system. Allomancy is powered by Preservation. Elantrians are powered by the Dor, a mixture of two other Shards. To gain access to a magic system, you usually need to graft a piece of that Shard's Investiture onto your soul. (Initiation is the technical term for it; in Allomancy, that takes the form of Snapping). Whenever you use that magic system, you're drawing energy from a Shard. It turns out, actually, that the Dor is the exception in this case, that it's very difficult to power when you travel off-world. We learn why in the essay for the Selish system in Arcanum Unbounded. I'll put it in spoilers below, in case you haven't read it yet. So, if a Mistborn goes to Sel and burns a metal from Sel, they are consuming a piece of Selish matter to activate their Spiritual Connection to Preservation, letting them draw on Preservation's energy to power their Allomancy in a specific way. (Ultimately, this energy will return to Preservation; Shards will never run out of power from people using their magics.) It is also possible to power a magic system using pure Investiture, if you can find Investiture in a physical form. (It takes many forms across all three Realms.) Burning atium draws directly on Ruin's power, since it's a physical piece of Ruin's Investiture. Drawing on the mists pulls directly from Preservation, and lets you apply that energy to whatever Allomancy you want. Stormlight appears to be a similar phenomenon; it's the Shard's power embodied physically, and it gets stored in gemstones until a Surgebinder can use it. But it's a wild card; the Investiture can be used in any number of ways, as opposed to the Investiture gained when a Mistborn burns steel, which can only provide energy in one specific form (Pushing). It is theoretically possible to 'hack' a magic system to be powered by another Shard's power, especially when you have access to a physical form of Investiture. This has happened to an extent with a certain character on Roshar, who consumes Stormlight instead of Breath (but hasn't figured out how to Awaken with Stormlight). Sand Masters, from the graphic novel, might be able to recharge their sand by exposing it to Stormlight or Mists instead of sunlight on Taldain. (One theory is that the sunlight itself is Invested, and carrying energy from Taldain's Shard.) But that isn't the usual way of powering a magic system, which involves a direct path to the Shard in the Spiritual Realm. How you get that path in the first place varies by magic system. For Allomancy and Feruchemy, there's a genetic component (with an additional Snapping required for Allomancy). For Surgebinders, it looks like if you behave certain ways and say certain Oaths, you bond a spren (which is a piece of a Shard). Awakeners can be anyone; all you need is to collect enough pieces of the Shard Endowment (and we've seen a certain Stormlight character with perfect pitch, who probably has some Breaths). For the most part, you need to be from a specific world to meet those requirements to gain that magic. Hemalurgy is a big exception, and one that the author of the Ars Arcanum has commented on; anyone, anywhere, can use Hemalurgy to steal any magic. All you need to do is know how. So, I hope this answers some questions (and, honestly, I hope it raises a bunch more for you). Don't quite take everything I said as gospel truth; the big picture is confirmed (Shards can power their magic anywhere in the cosmere), but some of the specifics are debatable (like whether water for Sand Mastery is the exact same as color for Awakening, or the specific forms of Investiture that are required for Initiation). But hopefully this gives you a good springboard into the deep end of realmatics, to take the plunge and look with a close eye at passages in Brandon's books to puzzle out how all this fits together in the underlying theory.

Brandon says, So having lots of Investiture in your soul can lead to bad consequences. But isn't Nalthis a counter-example to that idea? So let's disregard the God-King who has stuff going on we don't know about and the Returned, who have divine shardic influence. Any citizen who is rich enough, can get lots of Breath. I'm talking Bill Gates type of rich. Normal guy, Lots of extra breath. Like thousands. No consequences, right? From what we know, as Breath piles up, you just get more and more benefits. So I was thinking about possible consequences for Wax, and Seekers and Copperclouds, who were mentioned earlier and are extremley likely to become savants. So taking Spook as the premier (only?) example, he used so much Tin, that eventually, when he wasn't burning metal, he felt blind, and all the other senses were muted as well. But, he wasn't actually blind, he still saw normally, it just felt that way to him. So I'm going to use a lot of metaphors in this post. Anyway, instead of his eyes being able to adopt between "burning metal" and "no metal" and being able to process the info, the extra investiture permeating his soul made it so that only while he was using investiture he could process what he was seeing (and hearing). Which lead to over-enhanced senses. Anyway, my metaphor is that when a person is in a dark room, and light flashes, it takes time for the eyes to adopt back to darkness. Spook's eyes stopped adopting back to normal. Now, looking at Wax, we have storing weight, which he does a lot of. A consequence of that could be that when he is at his normal weight, he feels heavy. Maybe at normal weight he feels like a normal person would under heavy gravity. Maybe it makes him clumsier/more awkward if he's not storing weight. If he's pulling weight to make himself heavier, he's not awkward becuase the investiture compensates. This is all pure speculation. As a Coinshot, the only think I could come up with for Savantism is: you know the feeling when you hold your hands, plams facing each other, shoulder-width apart, pushing out, and another person is supporting your hands so they're not actually moving. Then when you try moving your hands together you get an odd, resistancy feeling. So for Wax, if he's not Pushing anything, maybe he has that type of feeling. Yes I know this is a weak idea, but it's fun to come up This post has been reported for attempting to skirt the rules stuff, even if it's wrong So next up, Seekers. Perhaps, the consequence for them is a feeling like a heavy silence pressing down on them or feeling like missing a sense, like being deaf. For Copperclouds, perhaps it would be feeling exposed, or over-exposed, something at phobia levels, or like a warm comforting blanket is missing. Then I was thinking metaphors for why too much investiture is bad. Using Brandon's own phrase, maybe it's like a deflated balloon on a smaller scale. Brandon decribed TLR as a deflated balloon after he used up the Shardpool. Maybe savants are deflated balloons on a smaller scale. If you burn metals but are not a savant, the balloon can return to normal shape, if you're a savant, it stretches too much, the balloon deforms, so consequences occur. I was imagining threads in a balloon, when a ballon deforms threads reach differently, or end up in different places. That's when you're not burning. While burining, the investiture running through you compesnates for anything that's happening. Or knitting, you have a knitted piece, alternating yarn is investiture, if it gets too thick, the whole thing deforms, stitches pulled too tight, loose areas etc. So Stormlight "rages" and metals are "burned" OTOH, Breath seems like a calmer thing. Breath -assiciation - meditation. My metaphor for people on Nalthis is that they have a two part soul. Instead of Investiture being interwoven into the fabric of the soul, there are two knitted pieces. One is Investiture-less, what you keep when you become a drab. Other is completely made up of investiture, can become large without affecting the other. So these are just a couple of my ideas I came up today. Also, examples of people holding large amounts of investiture: the God-King, TLR, and all Vessels. Well, the consequences for vessels skip the soul and go straight to burning the body, at least at first. But for God-King and TLR, we don't see any horrible consequences of the sort that were very obvious for Spook. Maybe too close association to a Shard for the God-King (Divine Breath) takes care of all the problems, and TLR held the same power as Harmony when he fixed Spook, so was able to pre-empivley make sure nothing would happen to him. I repeat, this entire post is pure speculation. Except for the question about wealthy Nalthians with lots of Breath and no consequences.

I've actually always been of the opinion that it refers to one of the Unmade, not one of the Heralds (or Radiants for that matter). If you actually look at the citation for that epigraph it is "Paragraph 27 of the Book of the 2nd Desk Drawer". We have two other quotes from that section of the Diagram as well, and they are talking about the Unmade.

When you realize Rogue One came out on the 16th of December in 2016, and you're all like: Oh wow. Sixteen is an important number.

Rock would make fun of you all. "Is not heavy, is lighter than bridge, air-sick lowlanders."

Jasnah was, as Navani put it, "really born thirty years old", so being MORE mentally mature than your age is not unique among the heroes. The difference is that Lift is putting (semi-)conscious effort to be the opposite. And so the moment of contrast look sharper. You probably cannot simultaneously be a fool, a madman, an orphan, and alive, but you're allowed to try.

Another question: Arclo claims that Nale could not kill him, and that the Skbybreaker apprentices stood very little chance. Yet, Aimia was "scoured" and the implication was that most of the inhabitants were slaughtered. I wonder if this is actually true or if the inhabitants simply broke themselves down into cremlings, waited for everyone to go away, and then quietly reformed into their body shapes. Also, given what we know of Aimans, why did humans want to slaughter them? I think there is something very important here. Looks like a targeted reread is in order.

Pure reaction a few moments after finishing Edgedancer: SQUEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE SHARD FORK SHARD FORK SHARD FORK IT IS THE INFAMOUS SHARD FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOORK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! SQUEEEEEEEE! SHARD FORK!!!!!!!!!!! *runs around in a rather large circle about three or four times* SQUEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE! SHARDFORK!!!!!!!! Friends reaction to my reaction: Winter, are you okay?

Kaladin and Shallan in the chams, and more particulary when they goes deep in confidences. So emotive... "Oh, storms. She smiled anyway." I think I almost cried reading this (and very very very few books can do this to me, and most of them only can once)

alright alright fine I give in too. here's my pic. nbd

Sounds like you could have a lot of fun with that! Booming "Fee-fi-foo-fum", refusing to be served by waiters named David, complaining that "these puny human portions are not sufficient to sate the hunger of a race of warriors!" The possibilities are endless! Must be hippy, all-natural, organic chicken! That, and you can blame your parents. Apparently the Dutch are the tallest people in the world, so you could yell "Why couldn't at least one of you have been from the Netherlands?! Did you even think about how that would affect me?" before you leave in a huff and slam the front door.

I, too, will post a picture: